Sunday, October 06, 2013

Looking too hard, and not looking

kw: book reviews, nonfiction, forecasting, prediction, statistics

We are remarkably good at cutting through the clutter in many situations. For example, we can talk to someone at a crowded party and pick out what they are saying in spite of the noise all around; and we can often spot a familiar face in a crowd. However, we sometimes see (or hear, etc.) things that are not there. When I was a child we would look for faces or other shapes in clouds. In a few minutes of looking, something suggestive is bound to appear. And there is a painting by my father of waves breaking on a rocky seashore. One of the big rocks looks like a leopard's head, and once I'd seen it, ever since I always see that leopard's head whenever I glance at the painting.

My father had no intention to hide faces in his paintings. Seeing the leopard's head is an example of a Type 1 error. If my father did actually hide faces in all his paintings, and I have noticed only this one (I have several others), then missing the faces that are there would be Type 2 errors. If I become so rapt in searching clouds for faces that I don't notice a friend approaching until he taps me on the shoulder, I have fallen victim to both kinds of error! We lazy, sedentary Westerners tend to do this frequently. Not so someone living hand-to-mouth in the woods.

For nearly everyone, through all the one or two million years of our evolution as brainy apes, hyper-alertness was required. Where it matters most, a Type 1 error does no harm, but a Type 2 error might be fatal. Running from a rock that looks like a leopard can make you look silly, but not running from a leopard that looks like a rock will probably get you eaten. Strangely, though we have kept our strong propensity to make Type 1 errors, as the risk of not noticing a real leopard has fallen, we are more and more likely to make Type 2 errors. In our modern world, in which we increasingly rely on forecasts and predictions, this leads to trouble.

Nate Silver, in his new book The Signal and the Noise: Why So Many Predictions Fail – But Some Don't, presents a number of similar examples that display our modern tendency to pick faces out of clouds while ignoring the approaching friend (or foe). I'll simplify matters and mention that he finds successful forecasting in only two areas: weather and baseball. Politics and stock picking and a number of other areas come in for a drubbing.

This simple diagram tells me all I need to know about "technical analysis" of stock prices. The data are the day-to-day percent change in the price of DuPont stock, from 1962 to mid September of this year. That's just over 13,000 data points. The X axis is the change on any particular day, and the Y axis is the change on the following day. This diagram shows perfect non-correlation! It is a 2-D bell curve, though with thicker tails than a Gaussian bell curve.

During those 51 years, the stock rose nearly 4,200%. That averages out to 7.7% per year but only 0.032% daily. Someone who bought $1,000 of DD stock in early January 1962 would have $43,000 today. Now, there's been a lot of inflation. That $1,000 in 1962 had the buying power of $7,740 today. So a half-century of waiting produced an effective multiplier of 5.5. That's 3% yearly after adjusting for inflation. Better than the bank.

The most extreme daily jumps are -20% and +10%. Stock speculators, particularly day traders, dream of taking advantage of the many days that a stock's price changes more than a percent or two. And such days are more common than if the distribution were strictly Gaussian. DuPont stock moves up at least 2.5% in a day about 5% of the time, and downward with similar frequency. That means, if you could pick just those up days, about 12 days each year, you could earn at least a 20% return yearly. That's 2-3 times what a buy-and-hold strategy will earn. Then, look at this:


The chart shows the historical record of DuPont stock, adjusted for splits. Focus on late 1974, late 1987, and late 2008 to early 2009. These show DD following the herd during market crashes, and represent downturns of 50%, 41% and 65%, respectively. If you could have avoided them, by selling just at the peak and buying back in at the bottom, your final return would be 9.69 times greater, for a total value of $416,000! Adjusted for inflation, that's over 8% return yearly (12.5% dollar-for-dollar yearly return).

Such figures stoke the dreams of day traders. But the first chart, showing no day-to-day correlation, dashes those dreams. Day traders work very hard for little return, and most lose. Some lose, big time, and some gain, but it is by accident either way. There are millions of day traders and other stock speculators. As Churchill wrote, "Even a fool is right once in a while."

Now we must differentiate prediction from forecasting. A prediction is a flat statement that a specific happening will or will not occur at some time or in some time horizon. For example, "There will be a magnitude 7 earthquake in Fremont within the coming year." A proper forecast includes the forecaster's uncertainty and is stated in probabilistic terms, as, "Projecting the trend of earthquakes in Fremont indicates that an earthquake of magnitude 7 or greater occurs about 3 times every 200 years." [Fremont was the imaginary State in the novel Space by James A. Michener]. One might add to such a forecast, a hybrid statement such as, "Fremont has not experienced an earthquake of magnitude greater than 6 in the past 100 years," which implies that "the big one" may be overdue. But it may indicate that conditions deep down may also be changing.

Earthquake prediction is the poster child of unpredictable phenomena. Intense study and research over decades, even centuries, have failed to yield a single valid prediction. Sports betting is close behind, except in the arena of baseball. Nate Silver once created a system he calls PECOTA, that rates the strength of teams against one another according to the past statistics of their players, and a well-known "aging curve" of the way performance changes over a player's career. Because baseball has such a rich data set, going back a century, and the principles needed to make useful forecasts are also well known, PECOTA and similar systems can evaluate players and teams at a level nearly equal to the best scouts. The computer can't quite replicate the humans, but it does give 'em a run for the money!

Why are forecasting and prediction so hard? Even though we have randomness at the deepest level of atomic phenomena, that randomness is constrained by the statistics of large numbers, and physics works very accurately to predict many systems, such as planetary orbits. Thus, though the path of an electron after passing through a hole may be uncertain, the distribution center of the paths of trillions of electrons (say, a millionth of an ampere for 0.1 second or so) will be very sharply defined and can be accurately measured, and the shape of the distribution tells you additional facts: the hole's size and shape. The much larger "distribution" consisting of the atoms making up a baseball mean that its flight, once thrown or batted, will be easily predicted.

The geological setting of an earthquake is not as simple as an electron. Perhaps this year, an earthquake might occur, large enough that the two sides of a fault will slip by each other by half a meter. That may be enough to put two kinds of rock in contact, that were not in contact before, which changes the likelihood of the next earthquake.

What about the weather? Air is in constant motion; its humidity and temperature, and thus its density, change constantly. How can anyone make a useful weather forecast? In some ways, we are still dependent on the "signs in the sky" that Jesus mentioned. In modern (18th Century) terms, "Red sky at morning, sailor take warning. Red sky at night, sailor's delight." Lore such as this is a compilation of patterns that happen over and over, so that generations of our ancestors took note and remembered. Yet now we can get a forecast up to a week or two ahead, complete with expected high and low, precipitation chances and intensity, and wind strength.

It's all done in a computer. Air may have complex behavior, but the physics of air motion and how it changes with temperature, pressure and humidity are well known. The 3D-gridded-cell models that run in supercomputers use surprisingly simple physics to determine how a 3D cell is influenced by the 6 cells it is in facial contact with, and the 8 cells at its corners. The reason supercomputers are used is that Earth is big. The surface area of the planet is 4πr², where r is 6,370 km: about 510 million km². Cells of half a km on a side, plus 0.1 km in depth (up to 12 km altitude) result in a Global Circulation Model (you'll see the acronym GCM in some weather web sites) with 1/4 trillion cells. It takes a lot of calculation to determine what will happen in the next quarter hour. There are 96 quarter hours in a day, and 672 in a week. To do all those trillions and quadrillions of calculations in only an hour or two requires today's largest computers. And the forecasters' computer gurus don't do it once, they run it several times with very small variations (the formal practice of selecting the variations is called Design of Experiments), to test the stability and sensitivity of the forecast to perturbations.

Weather forecasters have an incentive to get it right that others don't have. The reality is going to arrive tomorrow or the next day, it is visible to all, and it is no fun getting a call such as, "I have ten inches of 'partly cloudy' that I need to shovel off my driveway. Want to come over and help?" They also get a ton of research money from the Dept. of Defense, because good forecasts are crucial to military activities. Earth dynamic studies are different. Students of earthquakes can't observe the day-to-day conditions of a fault line. Its active zone is typically 8-15 km deep, and we can't yet drill a well that deep. Earthquakes are also rare. Sure, there are thousands of little ones, at the bottom of "measurable", every day, but there are trillions of weather events around the globe, every few minutes.

Mr. Silver entertains us with many, many stories of the vagaries of forecasts of all types. In the end, most phenomena are too difficult to forecast appropriately. Some involve living things. The cardinal rule of animal studies is, "Given any particular set of temperature, lighting, food availability and ambient noise, the rat will do whatever the rat wants to do." And this is in spite of lab rats being so inbred that their genetics are practically identical. The statistics of playing poker yield a few big winners, who work hard for the kind of edge they need to beat their fellow experts. But they love to be in a game that is well supplied with "fish": overconfident amateurs. A well-written computer package might tell a poker player the optimum betting strategy, but only if it is betting against other computers. The social aspects of the game, bluffing and speed or slowness of a bet for example, often provide a lot more of an edge than the math does. Carefully crafted intimidation works wonders. I don't expect a computer to master these aspects of the game for a number of decades (that's my forecast!).

The book's final example is the climate, particularly "global warming" or "climate change" or "greenhouse effect" or whatever the next buzzword will be. Climate is not weather. It is the setting in which weather happens. Climate changes unfold over multiple decades or centuries or millennia. Weather changes take seconds. In numerical analysis, this is the Stiffness problem. When something changes suddenly, it takes time for the effects to either move elsewhere or to die down. If you are interested in something with a 5-year cycle, such as El Niño (also called ENSO), the exact location and timing of today's sudden thundershower will not matter one tiny bit. If your interest is in human-induced greenhouse warming that began in the late 1700s, ENSO is an irritation at best. In fact, weather and medium-scale cycles such as ENSO are "noise" in the context of this book's thesis. Another researcher, later on, made clear a different view, that noise is really signals, but about stuff you aren't interested in at the moment.

This is like the crystal radio I made as a kid. It initially consisted of a long wire, running to a treetop, a piece of germanium crystal, and a "whisker", a wire that formed a diode with the germanium; and earphones attached to the whisker and the ground connection on the back of the germanium crystal. The diode "detected" the audio signal by separating it out of the radio frequency "hash". There was just one strong station nearby, so I could hear them pretty clearly. But later, as more stations came on the air (this was the 1950s), I could hear all of them at once. So, following a diagram in Mechanix Illustrated, I made a coil and paid a dime for a small capacitor and a piece of copper, to make a rough tuner. It could be tuned to resonate with one AM station at a time, so I could "tune out" the "noise" of the other stations. They were actually signals, just signals I didn't want right then.

The global greenhouse has warmed about 0.5°C (0.9°F) in a century, and perhaps 1°C (1.8°F) since 1750. Some of that may be warming since the Little Ice Age, which some consider a regional phenomenon, not a global one. But the current "ForecastFox for Mozilla" forecast for the next 24 hours indicates we'll have a 20°F swing tomorrow, from 75 in midafternoon to 55 overnight. You have to average out a lot of daily temperatures to see a change of a degree over 250 years. When you want weather, that is your signal. When you want climate, weather is noise, and lots of it.

The science of greenhouse warming is partly very well known, and partly not so well known. I learned to replicate the Arrhenius calculations from 150 years ago, when I was a pre-teen. Actual warming since his day has been about twice what he expected, because there seem to be amplifying factors. These are very poorly known. Does more cloud cover cool the atmosphere by reflecting more sunlight, or warm it by acting as a further thermal blanket? Or does it do one thing at a certain latitude and another elsewhere? If we do have a further warming by 2 to 4°C, will it shift the Hadley Cell north, or south, or not at all? (The northern edge of the Hadley Cell is a range of latitudes characterized by dry, descending air that form all the world's great deserts.) I've thought of buying land in central Canada, that is currently too cold to farm. Perhaps in 20 years it will be arable…unless the Hadley Cell shifts north and dries out Canada. Then maybe the Mojave would become a tropical paradise!

Y'know how to make a complex system into a positively unsolvable mess? Make it political. Both sides of the Climate debate are so politicized that they can only talk past each other. The tiniest proposal to set any policy is vigorously fought by every vested interest, even those who might benefit (the devil you know…). Heaven help us if weather forecasting ever gets politicized! It is already true that most forecasters err on the wet side: a 20% chance of rain is reported as a 40% or even 50% chance, because the ones rained on are less likely to complain, and those that aren't will feel they dodged a bullet. What if some "weather outcomes" become more politically correct than others?

By the way, I take issue with Silver's definition of statistical rain forecasts. He writes that if 40% of the computer models indicate rain in Chicago, and the rest don't, it is reported as a 40% chance of rain. Sounds logical, but it is quite different than that. The "chance of rain" has different meanings in spring (plus summer) and autumn (plus winter). Spring and summer squall lines pass through areas that are well predicted by most GCM programs. But a squall line is not a solid front of rain. It is a line of thunderstorms. A light squall line may have storms half a mile wide, spaced 2-3 miles apart, giving 20% of the area a 100% chance of rain. The forecasters just don't know which 20%, so the whole area is given a 20% chance of rain. A heavy squall line will have larger storms with closer spacing, and maxes out at about 80% coverage (though this will probably be reported as "near certain"). Fall and early winter storms tend to be solid and widespread, but subject to ripples several miles wide in the upper atmosphere. As a system rides up a ripple, it drops rain along a solid band dozens of hundreds of miles long but only about a mile wide or so. As it rides down, it dries out. The height of the ripples determines whether the overall chance of rain is 30% or 70% or somewhere between. The ripples drift along as system after system rides through, so it is very hard to tell exactly where the rain will fall. Timing is everything. Then, a lower-level storm that just dumps (ignoring the ripples) leads to those 100% forecasts, which are generally accurate.

In most arenas, Silver advocates using Bayesian analysis rather than "frequentist" simulations or estimations. These allow individualized forecasts for particular cases. An example is the probability of breast cancer in a woman in her 40s, who has just had the unwelcome news that a mammogram is "positive". The factors of a Bayesian calculation are:
  • x - Prior Estimate: the chance that a proposition is true.
  • y - Type 1 analysis: the chance that new data which indicates "Yes" is actually correct.
  • z - Type 2 analysis: the chance that the proposition is not true, in spite of the new data.
The data are usually noted as percents. The formula for a new estimate (a new x) is xy/(xy+z(1-x)). For this example, we find:


In this case, the woman may wish for a needle biopsy, but a bit of blood chemistry may be in order first. Enzymes in the blood can indicate whether a new cancer is likely to be slow growing, or faster. Is it slower (the most likely case)? She can wait a year for another mammogram. If the next mammogram is positive, re-do the analysis, replacing the 1.4% with 9.6%. Now the "new x" is just over 44%, and at the very least a biopsy is indicated. Most other forecasting methods don't use multi-step refinement. And by the way, if the next mammogram is negative (and no palpation can detect a lump, or any growth in an earlier lump), running the analysis with 9.6%, 10% and 75%, in that order, reverts to 1.4% as the "new x".

Those who follow this blog may wonder why it took me 3 weeks to read such a fascinating book. The writing is good and the examples are interesting, so that didn't slow me down. We have a lot going on, however, so I have had much less time for reading than usual. Retirement has been good to me so far, but I have to be careful not to take on too many projects at once. I completed a Real Estate course and passed the test in July. However, I will probably not seek a license or become a Realtor®, because there are simply too many other things I'd prefer to do. The change of style and reduced frequency with which I post is a similar effect. I used to post almost every lunch hour, doing research in off hours. I think I am working longer days than when I worked! Better busy than bored. Since retiring in February, I have put 24 items in my "job jar" file. Half of them, mostly the bigger ones, have been completed. One major item is awaiting an event that is at least a year in the future, but the preparations are nearly all completed. Others are smaller so I can take an odd half day to perform one. All things in their own time. In the meantime, I read when I can, and report what I read.

Monday, September 23, 2013

A loss for the atmosphere

kw: book reviews, nonfiction, climate change, argument

Jonathan Swift wrote, "You cannot persuade a man out of a belief that he wasn't persuaded into."

"Answer not a fool according to his folly, Lest thou be like to him -- even thou. Answer a fool according to his folly, Lest he be wise in his own eyes." – Proverbs 26:4-5 Young's Literal Translation

Let's take up the Bible passage first. It is akin to a koan, seemingly self-contradictory, and is best understood in the context of political disputation. The first sentence warns against letting your opponent (fool or not!) set the terms of the debate. For example, to answer either 'yes' or 'no' to the question, "Have you stopped beating your wife yet?" leads you into a trap. The second sentence is wiser. It is best understood in a paraphrase: "Don't be reasonable with an unreasonable person." If you suspect your opponent is crazy, you must be crazier.

That leads us to the other quote. Cases of religious conversion are but one example of experiences that people describe in very emotional terms. The most frequent phrase is, "Once I was blind but now I see." This also happens in other arenas, and in particular in the science of climate change, this is what Anna Rose was hoping for when she embarked on a month-long odyssey with Nick Minchin, a retired member of the Australian Senate, to interview scientists and others engaged in the debate over climate change, global warming, or whatever you may call it. The journey was sponsored by ABC in Australia, and led to a program aired in April, I Can Change Your Mind About Climate.

Anna Rose is chair of the Australian Youth Climate Coalition. As we find from reading her book Madlands: A Journey to Change the Mind of a Climate Skeptic, nobody's mind was changed. And as I saw at the ABC website, a poll of those who viewed the documentary TV program shows that few minds were changed at all. If anybody changed their opinion, it was probably in the direction of skepticism. Of 29,900 poll responses, 56% were either doubtful or dismissive of climate change ("Dismissive" alone was 48%) and 40% were concerned or alarmed. That leaves but 4% in the middle. This is to be expected. Even if a majority of people have no strong feelings about the subject, they are the least likely to watch a documentary with an argumentative format. The rest already had their minds made up, and probably watched to either cheer or groan as one side or another made telling points.

To tell the truth, from reading Madlands, I didn't see hardly any telling points made by the experts chosen by Ms Rose. It was clear from the outset that she was trying to bat way out of her league. She writes midway through of feeling that she was following the rules, while Nick was not. Well, of course not. He is a politician. From the beginning his agenda was winning over people who would watch the program, not answering any of the arguments made to him. He chose only one (formerly) respected scientist, and several more telegenic spokespeople.

The month of travel covered all the continents except Antarctica (I suspect ABC producers quailed at the cost of getting a film crew to the Ross ice shelf). Fairly early on, they visited the scientist most likely to make a dent in Nick's skepticism, Professor Richard Muller of UC Berkeley. A profound skeptic, Muller thought that the famous "hockey stick" graph of warming in the 20th Century was based on faulty measurements. Climate skeptic web sites abound with pictures of standard recording stations located near air conditioning equipment, or in the midst of concrete covered areas. Unwilling to believe NASA or NOAA or anybody else, Muller gathered all the data used for these calculations over the past century or so, billions of measurements, and had a team re-analyze them, eliminating the ones that were the most likely to be compromised. His team produced a temperature graph almost identical to the "hockey stick". He changed his point of view, at least to some extent. Prof. Muller now declares that the climate is warming at a surprising rate, and that our emissions of carbon dioxide are largely responsible: "…we are dumping enough carbon dioxide into the atmosphere that we're working in a dangerous realm."

Nick was not swayed. Maybe nudged just a tiny bit, but at that point, Anna should have seen the light herself, and called off the rest of the project. Muller was not one of her picks, but had a better case to make than any of them. The basic story is that Anna picked a series of reasonable and very qualified experts, while Nick picked primarily pit bulls. He didn't bother to try to convince her. He was aiming at the TV audience. The documentary provided him with a platform on which she had at most a cameo presence.

Madlands is her attempt to salvage something from a disaster. She makes point after point in the text, and in each case, I asked internally, "So why didn't you say that for the cameras?" It proved much too easy for her to be shocked speechless.

The climate debate is not about science. The science has been known for 150 years. I replicated Arrhenius's calculations more than 50 years ago. The modern refinement is to pin down feedback effects and nonlinear transitions. "Pin down" is not quite accurate. The greenhouse effect alone can account for at most a rise of 4°C if we increase carbon dioxide to 5-10 times its current level. That is bad enough. But recent (since 1980 or so) measurements indicate that changes in water vapor in the atmosphere, aerosol production, and so forth, might multiply greenhouse warming by a factor of between 1.5 and 4; the consensus is "about 3". That is the basis of the IPCC prediction of warming by a further 1.2°C to 4°C by 2050. Greenhouse effects alone would add less than a degree.

To effect a change in policy, one must convince policy makers, not just of the truth of your propositions, but that a cost-effective solution can be had, one that does not threaten to end their career. Rule Zero of Politics: "Where you stand depends on where you sit." Anna Rose's book and further work are intended to shift public opinion. She does, at least, understand that to turn a policy maker's stance it is necessary to change the stance of the constituency. Too bad it takes so long, because Rule One is "Moses in the Wilderness": it takes 40 years for the old generation and their old ideas to die out and a new generation to rise up.

Tuesday, September 17, 2013

The illusion of thinking clearly

kw: book reviews, nonfiction, thinking, logical fallacies

A few years ago I met someone at a reception. He told me he was a philosopher, and that his specialty was the fallacies of formal logic. I happen to know that there are 16 formal fallacies, which are errors in the logic of an argument. I also know, and had recently read a treatise upon, the informal fallacies, which are unknown in number, but there are more than 100 (the Wikipedia article "list of fallacies" notes 59). For some reason, this quite incensed my new acquaintance, to the point that I was concerned he may become violent (a common informal fallacy on his part!).

Winston Churchill said, "Even a fool is right once in a while." This caution alerts us to avoid the most common informal fallacy, the ad hominem attack, which we could describe as, "You must be wrong because you are a bad person", or, "…because I don't like you", or, "…because you are a [substitute your stereotype of choice]". Interestingly, this fallacy is not discussed in The Art of Thinking Clearly by Rolf Dobelli. I suppose he felt is has been sufficiently treated elsewhere, a great many elsewheres. But he does discuss 99 common errors that are so common, so very common it is a surprise any of us can decide anything at all!

Dobelli is Swiss and writes in German; the book was translated to English by Nicky Griffin. Kudos to the translator. Many translations from German produce nearly unreadable English. Clearly, Dobelli has a smooth, conversational writing style which Griffin has captured masterfully. It is great fun to read.

I can't hope to comment on more than a few of the items discussed. I picked a few favorites:

  • Reciprocity, in the chapter "Don't Accept Free Drinks" – Dobelli calls appeals for donations that come in the mail with a "free gift" inside a "kind of gentle blackmail" (I'd call them extortion rather than blackmail). An allied principle is TANSTAAFL: There Ain't No Such Thing As A Free Lunch. Depending on how much spending authority you have, the "free lunch" could range from sports tickets to a "free" vacation. Then there is all the "free" stuff offered if you'll spend 90 minutes listening to a timeshare presentation. It is good to learn to say, "I don't think I can afford your 'free gift'."
  • Confirmation Bias, in two chapters, the second being "Murder Your Darlings" – This has two sides. One is the increasing tendency for search engines, led by Google, to keep track of your preferences and to use them to rank the list of returns from a search you make. As time goes by, you'll only get "hits" that confirm your prejudices. That's why it is a good idea not to search when you are logged in to a Google service such as Blogger, Drive or GMail (or one such as Yahoo Mail if you search using Yahoo). Search as anonymously as possible if you want less biased results. The second side is the tendency of writers to dwell on themes that they love and to give short shrift to others, even if they are trying to discuss "all sides" of an issue. Arthur Quiller-Couch devised the motto, "Murder your darlings", meaning to eliminate the redundant text that inevitably fills your writing about those most-loved themes; pare those sections down to match the less-favored sections.
  • Induction, in the chapter "How to Relieve People of Their Millions" – This is a favorite of mine, based on an ancient scam. Someone who is lucky several times in a row may be considered extra favored or blessed, and if you get tricked by your own good luck, it can lead to a feeling of immortality. It also leads to unneeded depression when your luck turns. But it also explains why "financial advisers" invest each client's funds in a different collection of investments (Those who invest all funds equally are called mutual fund managers, and are more likely to have a modicum of honesty!). Here is a key datum: multiply 2 by itself 10 times, and the result is 1,024. Pick a yes/no question, such as "will the market go up or go down?" Send about 1,000 people an e-mail in which you explain why you think the market will go up in the coming week, and send another 1,000 an e-mail in which you explain why you think it will go down. After a week, it has done one or the other. Suppose it went down. Now send an e-mail to just the second group making a new prediction, again of the yes/no variety. The third week, e-mail just the 500 for whom you've been right twice, with a further prediction, and so forth. After five weeks, assuming you actually started with two groups of 1,024, you now have 64 people who have received five accurate predictions. At this point, ask to be paid for further predictions. Let's say they all agree (keep the cost low at first). Now things get complicated. After your next prediction, send an apologetic e-mail to the 32 who saw you "flub", and offer to refund their payment; send a self-congratulatory e-mail to the others, but don't lay it on too thick. You are likely to keep some of the ones who got the apology. Anyway, after a total of 10 predictions, you now have at least 2 people who think you are infallible! You can ask for stratospheric prices for your answers. Investment advisers are not so blatant about it, but by spreading around their clients' funds, they can avoid being wrong too frequently.
  • The Black Swan, in the chapter "How to Profit From the Implausible" – The actual fallacy is to think that unlikely events are less likely than they really are. For example, how likely is it that someone could throw a basketball over their house, and have it go through the hoop in the back yard? One in a million, or a billion? Yet there are at least two videos out there showing just this happening. One is shown a couple times a year on America's Funniest Home Videos on ABC. Professional statisticians tend to analyze every distribution as a "normal" distribution, even though very few natural phenomena follow a bell curve. For example, women's height is found to be normally distributed, but household income is not. Also, the daily change in a stock's price is typically analyzed as a normal distribution, but large changes are much, much more likely than such a model predicts. Dobelli claims that unlikely events are getting even more likely, and even more consequential, because our civilization is more strongly affected by events outside "the usual range", like a 100-year flood. Before we began building lots of fragile houses some 10,000 years ago, a 100-year flood simply meant moving camp to higher ground for a week. Now it means high insurance premiums (if you have flood insurance in the first place). Also, those who make big incomes don't work for others. Dobelli's advice is to work in an area where a big break can bring big returns, but to save and invest as though such a big break may never come. If it comes, you can profit from it, and if it doesn't, you will have provided for your future.
  • Feature-Positive Effect, in the chapter "Why Checklists Deceive You" – We notice things that are there (but not even all of those!), but it is very hard to notice what isn't there. This is the crux of the Sherlock Holmes story "Silver Blaze", where the important clue was that a watchdog didn't bark. Only Holmes would notice such a fact. Everyone else was busy about evidence they were able to collect, because it existed. Double-talk "explanations" about why something went wrong are solidly based on carefully omitting key facts in the midst of a blizzard of less relevant, but attractive, facts (a related fallacy). Dobelli tells of Beethoven's Ninth Symphony. During its premier many wept. He asks, "Would we be less happy without [it]? Probably not." Had "the Ninth" never been written, we'd never know what we were missing anyway. In the same way, we notice nothing in particular when we are totally well. We really notice any disease or injury.
In a reference section at the end we find 50 pages of bibliographic information, which the author says could easily have become several hundred pages. There is a lot of "thinking about thinking" being written up in the literature. This book is the most accessible of them all in my experience.

Saturday, September 14, 2013

Family drama with a wink

kw: book reviews, nonfiction, essays, humor, family relations

As writers the mother and daughter don't compete, they complement. Philadelphian Lisa Scottoline and her daughter Francesca Serritella write "Chick Wit" for The Philadelphia Enquirer. You know how it goes. Write a column long enough, and you can collect a few dozen into a book. These witty ladies have been at it long enough that this is their fourth book together. I don't now what other writing the daughter does, but the mother is also a mystery writer, with 19 titles so far.

'Nuffa that. Meet Me at Emotional Baggage Claim is a great read. One might say that Lisa and Francesca are following a trail blazed by Erma Bombeck, one of my favorite writers, though a generation earlier than Lisa. They write with the same pointed humor, but with even more warmth and joy. While their most frequent subject is each other, they discuss friends, pets, travel (with each other or with others), food, and emotions—they're Italian, so feelings worth having are worth having loudly.

If I count right, the book contains 73 articles. Short ones of 2-4 pages. That made it very well suited to the way I often read: squeezing in a few pages between other stuff, or even during TV commercials. A session on "the throne" is good for 2 or 3 items (don't tell me you don't take a book in there).

There isn't a lot else I can say. I didn't pick out a favorite essay, because it would be like picking my favorite day out of the last ten days of almost perfect early fall weather.

Wednesday, September 11, 2013

The reflected writer

kw: book reviews, nonfiction, memoirs, autobiographies, writers

I find it oddly fitting, on this 12th anniversary of "9/11", to review the memoirs of a British subject who was interned by the Japanese near Shanghai in the 1940s, saw the only city he had known destroyed, and lived the rest of his life in an England where he never quite fit. His productive period began with his years as a widower in his 30s raising three young children.

Many years ago I read a book and a couple of stories by J.G. Ballard and found them beyond my reach, incomprehensible. Now having read Miracles of Life: Shanghai to Shepperton, and Autobiography, I realize that Ballard's fiction brings us into the ways he coped with the overwhelming losses he had suffered. In one way he is not unique. Many were the expatriate children raised in the Shanghai of the 1930s and 1940s, who came to their teen years in time to suffer internment, who were daily familiar with the sight of the dead, who saw, and sometimes experienced, the appalling cruelties of soldiers trained in the centuries-old bushido ethic, for whom their own lives meant nearly nothing, and those of all others, even less. In another way he is unique. He learned to express what these experiences deposited in him.

Ballard's writing sold better in America and Europe than in Britain. The British of the 1950s and even to the 1980s were too stoic to accept writing that laid bare the emotions he was expressing, in his deceptively bland prose. That's what I remember of The Drowned World: imagery that swung from the banal to the horrifying, in writing so matter of fact that scenes I'd ordinary vomit out could slip in almost unaware. To someone whose favorite Science Fiction previously had been the Lensman series by E.E. "Doc" Smith and the Robot books of Isaac Asimov, one who subscribed wholeheartedly to Campbell's dictum to "present a tough problem and then solve it", Ballard's surreal emotional landscapes and apparently goal-less plots were beyond comprehension.

Ballard dealt in metaphor, and almost single-handedly wrought a sea change in the S.F. genre through the 1970s and onward. Few have been able to publish works as mysterious as his, but many have drawn from his example more rounded characters, more realistic plots—that is, plots more prone to surprising side channels and seemingly meaningless meanders—and stories that need not be placed in a deep future so the writer can get away with fantasy in the guise of SciFi.

I once childishly said to my mother that it seemed the Star Trek series was about colonialism. She retorted that no, it was about exploration and learning. Over time, I saw she was right. I noticed that the chief characters were well-read and thoughtful, not the mindless heroes of sword-n-sorcery nor the banally evil colonial masters of true colonialism. Ballard's experiences furnished him with material for decades of thoughtful analysis of himself and his fellows, to produce a science fiction that needed just a bit of "suppose this small fact were different, then what?" to bring about a new mental landscape for us to explore with him.

Now that I am a tad more mature, perhaps I can read his fiction and get more out of it. I can't wait to try. (Ballard died in 2009, and this is his last book, started soon after his terminal diagnosis in 2007.)

Monday, September 09, 2013

Small book on a large subject

kw: book reviews, nonfiction, essays, memoirs, religion, philosophy of science

He claims to be an agnostic, one who prays and studies the Talmud daily and keeps kosher. Now age 98, Herman Wouk has written novels that span three generations of readers. While he still can, he has written of his exploration of the boundaries of science and religion, based in part on three conversations with Richard Feynman, and a great deal of his own experience. In their first conversation, Feynman asked him in parting if he knew calculus. He confessed he didn't, and Feynman responded, "You had better learn it. It is the language God talks."

The Language God Talks: on Science and Religion is Herman Wouk's memoir of how his stories developed in the context of his own religious convictions, and the people whose influence meant so much to the way they came together. He confesses that all attempts to learn calculus defeated him. Yet he has persisted nearly a full century in learning the original language God talks, the Hebrew of the Torah and its ongoing commentary, the Talmud.

The Hebrew itself is not really the language of which he speaks, but rather the incisive reasoning behind these great books. As he imagines himself saying to Feynman in a fourth conversation that he wished had happened, study of the Talmud, and earlier the debates and reasoning that produced it, represent the mental recreation of generations of thoughtful Jews during centuries with no technology of entertainment, no telephones or TVs or iPods (I wonder what the great sages would make of Wikipedia, whether they would contribute to it enthusiastically, or shun it. Probably the former!).

There is more insight into what it means to be Jewish in this little book than in any other I have read, of any size. I look upon the continued existence of the Jews as the foundational proof of God's existence. As a prophet wrote (here I paraphrase), God chose Israel not because they were greater or stronger or better or more numerous than the nations around them, but because He desired them for a testimony to His name. While He promised repeatedly to bless Israel, this "blessing" has been rather backhanded: they have endured continual attempts to exterminate them, for more than 3,000 years. Indeed, the first mention of Israel outside the Torah is an inscription in Egypt, dated about 1210 BCE, announcing that Israel had been "totally defeated". That long-dead pharaoh Merneptah spoke too soon.

But Wouk is the great writer here, not this poor scribbler, and dwells for a third of the book on his fictional character Aaron Jastrow, whose sermon "Heroes of the Iliad" is included as a coda to the book. That sermon, which morphed into a meditation on the meaning of Job's suffering, is the core of Wouk's belief and a most powerful statement of the Jewish understanding of the delicate choreography of God and His people.

What Wouk says indirectly I will state more frankly. God's own writing, His Bible, states that humans, "male and female", are in God's image and after His likeness. And just as we begin as infants and grow through a long process, so does God! If you read through the Torah, the Songs and the Prophets with a view to God as a juvenile, growing to maturity, you can reliably sort the books in time. The great figures of Genesis, particularly Abraham and Moses, sometimes had to talk God out of doing something rash. The man for whom the nation is named, Israel, formerly Jacob, was so named because he "wrestled with God, and prevailed". This view will be seen as rank heresy by my Christian colleagues, but I think a Talmud scholar would understand.

Friday, September 06, 2013

When the church replaces God

kw: book reviews, nonfiction, memoirs, religion, cults, brainwashing

About 11:00 PM last evening, I finished reading the saddest, most disturbing book I've encountered this year. After six hours of tossing and turning, I realized I need to review it and get a few things off my chest so I can put it behind me. The book, written by Lauren Drain with the help of Lisa Pulitzer, is Banished: Surviving My Years in the Westboro Baptist Church.

Lauren didn't want to leave WBC. She was 14 when her father, who had been making a film documentary about Fred Phelps and his little congregation, became a convert and moved the family to Topeka, Kansas to live on "the block", as the collection of houses surrounding the sanctuary building is known. It was a rough transition, but over time she devoted herself wholeheartedly to WBC and its ways. Hers was the first family to join since the 1970s.

WBC consists mostly of descendants of the pastor, Fred Phelps, and their spouses and children. He started the congregation as a young man, and there were lean years, but he put himself through law school, and later many of his extended family became lawyers also. They became Phelps Chartered and got rich litigating civil rights cases. Although tithing is expected (demanded and enforced) of all members, the church is awash with money from the PC firm members' tithes.

Although in most ways Lauren was warmly accepted by a number of Phelps girls her age, she learned that she would never quite match up or catch up to them. They had been raised in the WBC way, which means doing every single little thing the pastor's way, as enforced by his leading daughter Shirley Phelps-Roper (Phelps females don't give up their names upon marriage, but hyphenate or simply keep their name). To a member of WBC the pastor's word is law, and Shirley is considered the spokesperson of the Holy Ghost. It seems there is no Son of God in their theology, perhaps because the pastor's sons are all rather passive, and those who aren't have left the congregation.

Most of the book details Lauren's struggles to fit in and to comply with the extreme demands of WBC and even more extreme demands of her father. Steve Drain comes across as a real nutcase. He is highly intelligent and creative, but he is clearly so emotionally insecure he has to rigidly enforce his control over every aspect of his family members' lives. In that he resembles his mentor, the pastor.

Lauren loved picketing, and felt a thrill of self-righteousness whenever she and her fellow picketers were scolded or reviled by passers-by or counter-protesters. Of course, she didn't think of it as self-righteousness at the time. She had been taught that only WBC members, in good standing, who had a near-perfect and sinless life had any chance of going to heaven. Perhaps a few others might be among God's chosen, but only if they were actively speaking out against America's corruption and tolerance of homosexuality.

Ah, the "fag" issue. The church's web site is titled God Hates Fags. Fred Phelps is a high-performing person, a real straight arrow, an Eagle Scout, admitted to West Point at age 17. He visited the campus once, then almost immediately rejected the notion of attending and managed to struggle through two or three lesser schools to complete a degree. His extreme anti-gay activism dates from this time, though it became even more extreme when the Gay Rights movement got under way in the 1970s. Lauren reports the known facts, including that if "that weekend at West Point" is ever mentioned by an interviewer, Phelps reacts violently and terminates the interview.

I have read items by a few folks who speculate that he had some kind of homosexual encounter at West Point, and most think he is secretly gay. I think it more likely that he became the "designated victim", to use a term familiar to boys who attended a boarding school. He probably got a thorough reaming out. And it is likely that he became terrified by his own reaction to the activity. Maybe and maybe not. The fact remains that he is emotionally insecure, and in recent years he has become frankly insane.

By the age of 21, after seven years in Topeka, Lauren was working as a nurse. She could see a strong double standard of performance, depending on whether you were a Phelps. But she kept that to herself. However, at church Bible studies, she wanted to know what various Bible verses meant. Not only the tiny collection of verses on which WBC activities and attitudes are based, but all of them. At first Shirley and others might try to explain, but at one point she began asking question like this: "Why do we tell people to repent, when we know it won't do them any good? They are already destined to hell." She was scolded and intimidated for asking such questions, and they intimated that she might go to hell for being "divisive".

The WBC heaven is going to be populated by Phelpses, and hardly anyone else. Sounds like a lonely place. Lauren had already seen several banishments, and then she experienced it herself. WBC cannot tolerate independent thinking, and she was out. Her parents disowned her. After work one day at her nursing job, her father gave her 3 hours to pack, then drove her to a hotel where he'd booked her a room for a couple days. That was that. It was near the end of 2007. In the years since, she has had to learn life skills that are denied to those "on the block". She tried to stay in some kind of contact with her parents, but now hasn't spoken to them for a few years.

Amazingly, she remains a spiritual person. Many would reject God along with the church. She has not. Helped at first by a boyfriend's mother, she learned a new way to understand the Bible and God's ways. Lauren is in the early stages of building a new life with a new understanding of herself, society, and God. Her closing words are, "I don't believe that God rejoices in tragedies, calamities, disease, pain and grief. In my faith, He has better things to do."

Amen. The two Testaments contain more than 30,000 verses. Most Christian traditions emphasize a message that is backed up by 2,000 to 3,000 verses. The strict WBC theology relies heavily on about 100 verses, and twists another thousand or so to fit, while ignoring the rest. The god of WBC is not the God I believe in, not the God that Christians and Jews know from our Bible.

Thursday, September 05, 2013

A bibliophilic thriller

kw: book reviews, nonfiction, crime, books, libraries

The urge to collect is oddly human. Few other animals collect objects, and those that do, such as nesting birds, do not maintain permanent collections, nor become hoarders. What is the difference between a hoard and a collection? The index. Thus, libraries and museums result from turning hoards and accumulations into collections.

Huge industries subsist and even prosper from the urge to collect. Interestingly, the priciest objects, in monetary terms, are those that have no other value except as something collected. Fine art is at the top of the scale. A somewhat distant second is rare books and manuscripts. I wonder if the reason that a unique book sells for less than a unique painting or sculpture is that it has a use: you can read it, and the books that command the highest prices are those nobody would read. I just checked "first edition" on eBay and sorted by price. There are 7 items, out of about a million, with an asking price of $950,000 or greater. All for books you wouldn't be obtaining for reading purposes.

Even in bad times, collectors spend a lot, and in the worst of times, the wealthiest collectors continue to spend, unfazed by the poor economy. Some spend more, hoping for bargains as people who are running out of money auction off their treasures. Thus, the most lucrative period for book thieves was the Great Depression of the 1930s. A particular theft, of a nearly unread book, in 1931 led to a sea change in the attitude of librarians and law enforcement about book theft. Unraveling the case cracked open a ring of book thieves and crooked dealers, the most notorious up to that time, as chronicled in Thieves of Book Row: New York's Most Notorious Rare Book Ring and the Man Who Stopped it, by Travis McDade.


Edgar Allen Poe lived only 40 years, and was an active author for about 22 years: his first publications were poems, from 1827, and his first prose story was published in 1832. His second published poetry collection, a tiny volume really, was Al Aaraaf, Tamerlane and Minor Poems, in 1829. The edition of 400 was poorly received, and most were discarded unsold. Fewer than twenty copies survive, but the most celebrated has come to be a copy that made its way to the New York Public Library, via the Lenox Library, upon its opening in 1911. Ignored for 20 years, and protected by security practices that were exceptional for the times, it was nonetheless stolen in January 1931, whence began a hunt that crossed several state lines, though the book itself did not.

The book itself is inconsequential. Thieves and crooked book dealers (in the 1920s and 1930s, that term was a redundancy) know that it isn't worthwhile stealing the rarest, most valuable books, because every copy is well known, so to whom can you sell it without being arrested? A book having between 10 and 100 or so known exemplars is a safer target, and worth the trouble of bleaching or otherwise erasing the library marks (there are always library marks, even in this era of electronic 'tattle tape' protection systems).

And why steal from libraries? It is a great deal safer than stealing from a personal library, because libraries are public! Turn-of-the-Century America was in the midst of a shift in rare book possession. Prior to about 1900, a bibliophile could amass a costly book collection, and might sometimes sell some, but more usually, his (very rarely, her) heirs would auction the estate through an established book house. The book dealers were used to selling and re-selling the same book as it passed from private collection to private collection. The notion of establishing a legacy, and of endowment, began taking hold in late Victorian times, however, and the book collectors' heirs were more likely to donate the books to a major library. Perhaps the collector, upon finding no heir who loved books as he did, would will them to a library. Once there, they were typically there forever.

Of course, libraries weed out their stacks periodically, but do not discard their rarities. Those are intended to remain for eternity, for the benefit of scholars. So by about 1920, book dealers were faced with a thinning supply of rare, and thus pricy, books. A few began to commission thefts. Other thieves took note, and got into the book "business". Before long, any dealer who remained in business had learned not to inquire too closely into the source of a box or bag of books at very attractive prices.

Library "security" practices, being nearly nonexistent, allowed a brisk trade in these moderately rare books. Only a few libraries made much attempt to stem the tide. NYPL was one, with an effective system. But the system did have a few tiny holes, and a certain book thief and two accomplices must have thought the stars had all lined up perfectly when they were able to obtain the library's copy of Al Aaraaf and two other books of similar value, and get them out the door (down 3 stories and across a large, crowded, echoing hallway). The 3 books were soon in a safe owned by Harry Gold, where at least the Poe book sat until its retrieval many months later.

I found it hard to figure out who was "the man who stopped it." I find it a tossup between G. William Bergquist and Felix Ranlett. Seems it took them both. Ranlett was in Boston, at the outskirts of the book ring's activity. In the juiciest sentence in the book, McDade writes, regarding a related theft in Boston, "In the grand tradition of library theft, a person with little prior experience in the subject was assigned to handle the matter for the [Boston Public Library]."

Once the action returns to New York, Bergquist is at its center, so I suppose he is the one. Certainly, he engineered the turning of a certain Babyface Mahoney into a cooperating stooge, and the arrest of a certain Harold Clarke and eventually Harry Gold, who were behind the Poe theft, though the thief was Sam Dupree, in their pay.

It has been written, most famously by Doc Smith who wrote the Lensman books, that what technology can create, technology can duplicate or defeat. Tattle tapes and other electronic measures are the current weapons of choice in the arms race to reduce library book theft. A recent estimate is that major libraries lose about 5% of their rare book collections annually. That is about half what the figure was a century ago. There is a trade-off between the cost of better security systems, and the cost of just buying replacement copies. Most first editions sell in the range of a few hundred to a few thousand dollars. Hiring armed security costs $100,000 yearly, or more, and you can replace a lot of lost books for that. The system most small libraries use costs $20,000 to install and set up, and a few thousand yearly to maintain.

Thieves is a joy to read. McDade has the rare talent to pack a book with facts and keep the writing enjoyable. The book doesn't look large, but it is densely set in 9pt type, so there is a lot there, backed up by about 400 notes and references. Well worth the reading.

Sunday, September 01, 2013

Made stronger in his affliction

kw: book reviews, nonfiction, librarians, illnesses, memoirs

In 1972, I experienced three significant events. My wife divorcing me was the least significant, in the overall scheme of things. Next, as I count it today, my mother's sister's husband divorced her. Most significant, from a long-term perspective, was the story she told me, during a visit shortly after the other two, nearly simultaneous events. My uncle was a rough man, yet wonderful in ways. A geology professor and well-honored; a classically trained pianist who had taken umbrage at my guitar rendition of "Moonlight Sonata" (movement 1 only, guitar is only capable of 2-octave chords and the Sonata uses 3+ octaves); father of my biggest group of cousins and a great grill chef. Yet my aunt told of a peculiar affliction he managed to keep secret from everyone but her. She said that often, at the end of a day, he'd go a little crazy, stomping around for a while, and groaning or roaring. "Sometimes," she said, "he would hit himself, and even knock himself out with his own fists." She attributed it to self-hate. I knew the verse in Ephesians, "No man ever yet hated his own flesh, but nourishes and cherishes it." I didn't comment, but marveled and remembered her words. I have had occasion in later years to know a stunning variety of people, and learned compassion for their afflictions. I learned that apparent self-hate is usually a distorted kind of self-love. I know people with several kinds of mental illnesses, and some whose symptoms were quite distressing and disturbing. But none I have met are as afflicted as my uncle, so far as I knew.

Reading Josh Harnagrave's amazing memoir has brought it all together for me. In The World's Strongest Librarian: A Memoir of Tourette's, Faith, Strength, and the Power of Family we learn of Josh's titanic struggle to live with Tourette Syndrome. His case is one of the most severe on record.

In the following I will use the abbreviation PwT for "person with Tourette's". PwT's experience numerous involuntary actions that are called "tics". A Tourette tic is, we learn, like a sneeze, but imagine every possible level of sneeze, from a silent jerk to a tiny "choo", all the way to something that seems it will blow your head off and can be heard a county away. Some sneezes we can anticipate, and perhaps stifle, or press our philtrim to stop, but others happen suddenly and without warning. Now imagine the smaller ones happening a few times per minute, and so on. A PwT may experience many smaller tics without noticing: grimaces, tiny sounds, rapid blinking and head jerks. The classic Tourette tics I read about many years ago are less common: louder grunts and shouts, even spoken words, seemingly picked at random from a common vocabulary of one-syllable words.

A side note at this point. The "travesty" program gathers all possible strings of 1 to 3 characters, including blanks and punctuation, from some moderate size text, such as a Shakespeare play or a short story by Hemingway. It arranges these statistically according to frequency of use. Then it randomly picks text snippets from this database and strings them together. The result is a piece of text that can be read aloud, is meaningless, but sounds like something written by that author. Many longer strings make actual words. Here's the interesting point. Travesties in English always contain numerous examples of the word "shit". The reason is simple. "sh" and "s" are the most common word endings, while "t" and "it" are very common word beginnings. Divorce them from the words they started with, mash them together statistically, and you get a lot of shit! (along with "st" and "sht" and so forth). Accidental occurrences of other popular swear words are not nearly so common in travesties. In addition, "shit" is one of the easiest words to say.

When a PwT is having strong vocal tics, if the sounds resemble words, they are likely to be words that are easy to say, and "shit" tops the list. Thus arose the common perception that PwT's swear constantly. Actually, they don't. A few who have more frequent vocal tics make such words mainly by accident. They have no more control over the sound than any of us have over a sneeze, once it begins. If a series of vocal tics is a series of swear words, the PwT probably has partial control, and is swearing his (rarely her) heart out, with good reason!

I won't attempt to summarize Josh's life story. Rather, two items stand out. Firstly, in his late twenties, he began having more violent tics, which began when he slugged himself, drawing blood. Throughout the book, he describes how he could sometimes control the tics for a short time, but this would be followed by a more severe series of outbursts. He had a kind of theory that a certain amount of energy had to be expended in tics each day, and it was better to have a lot of littler ones. Once he began having such dangerous tics, he became more desperate to learn to control them. He had learned that vigorous exercise seemed to quell the tics for a time, or perhaps he was channeling their energy into his iron-pumping motions. But this resulted in great strength, and he was getting seriously hurt. Then (the second item) he stumbled on an extreme strength trainer named Adam T. Glass, who taught him a different way to think about himself and Tourette's. In particular, he needed to think about motions, and which ones helped or hurt. Over time, Josh began to focus on breathing. With time and patience and effort, he gained a measure of control. Spoiler alert: Then Adam confided that he is autistic. Josh writes that it took a different kind of mind to see through what others could not.

This is not the end of the story. Today Josh is 35 or so, and has found that some techniques that once helped have become less effective, but by focusing on motions that help or hurt, has learned to modify what he does to retain some semblance of balance and control. In all this, I am amazed at the composure and support he gets from his wife. He and his family are Mormon, and at times in his life he was helped by his faith. He explains some aspects of Mormonism "from the inside". He is closer to an agnostic stance now, yet acknowledges the comfort faith can bring.

I wonder how my uncle and aunt would have fared if my uncle's affliction, which was probably Tourette's, were more appropriately dealt with. He had apparently learned to bottle up his tics while in the classroom or among us, but paid for it with damaging outbursts later. He lived to be nearly 75. I hope Josh does better than my uncle did. He certainly has a better handle on it than anyone had 40 years ago. His web site contains a blog and helpful links for PwT's. And you can find more about Adam T. Glass here.

Wednesday, August 28, 2013

Man's inhumanity to everything

kw: book reviews, nonfiction, animal rights, polemics

The book jacket blurbs claim that Rory Freedman has become the "rock star advocate" for animal rights. It helps to have a bestseller on the shelves (Skinny Bitch, 2005, with Kim Barnouin), but there is little further evidence. However, she is a compelling writer. Her new book, solo authored, is Beg: A Radical New Way of Regarding Animals.

The book begins on an autobiographical note, but personal stories thin out rapidly. This is a manifesto for the vegan lifestyle, and an excessively preachy listing of awful things being done to animals, whether it is pet breeding and animal showing, food animals—from eggs and milk to steaks and chops—or hunters' targets, she lists the worst of the worst as exposed primarily by PETA (People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals).

It is a fact that many people mistreat animals. More to the point, people who feel otherwise powerless mistreat each other, animals, their dwellings and possessions, and even themselves. Also, a certain number of men (and a few women), at every level of wealth and power, are psychopaths and abuse everything as long as they can get away with it; the stupider ones can't even think ahead far enough to get away with it and so become career criminals.

But most folks aren't abusers. Case in point: I've worked at a "meat packing plant", that is, a beef slaughterhouse. I wasn't working on the killing floor, but in a cleanup area. But once in a while, if I got to work early, I'd wander onto the killing floor and observe. It was an efficient operation, and while speed was of the essence, once I got over the "gross factor", I observed that the man using the captive bolt "stunner" (it splits the brain) was careful, and took an extra second to be sure the beeve was indeed "stunned". He had the power to slow the line long enough to repeat the stun if needed and I saw him do so once. He said when I asked him, that he'd once had a poorly stunned animal go onto the line, and, "The sounds it made gave me the willies! Never again!". Was this plant better than most, or average, or what? I don't know. Yes, there are abuses, but most people do have a conscience.

Ms Freedman covers all the bases, so far as I can tell. I suggest that everyone read this book, and then investigate for yourself, what level of animal abuse is realistically out there. I take it as a given that the PETA data are exaggerated. But, as Churchill said, "Even a fool is right once in a while", and the PETA folks are no fools. Just driven, and afflicted with tunnel vision.

The book's last couple of chapters make a case for being at least vegetarian, and for being vegan if at all possible. She claims, as many have, that the vegan lifestyle is healthier and that vegans live longer. This is an issue I have followed for decades. To date, the premise cannot be either proven or disproven. However, I do have a clue. The largest group of vegetarians on Earth is found in India, where the majority of the people eat no meat (I don't know about eggs or fish, but adults in India use no milk either, because nearly all are lactose intolerant). Life expectancy in India is 67 years, compared to 77-79 for Western cultures. Of course, India is rapidly rising from Third World status of just a couple decades ago, so we need to stay toned on this one. The public health infrastructure there is comparable to America 60-80 years ago, but improving rapidly. However, I know a great many people of Indian heritage who have lived in the U.S. for decades, and maintained their traditional, vegetarian cuisine. They don't seem to live exceptionally long. And, it is quite possible for a vegetarian to become obese. Fat people die sooner than more ordinary folk. And let's remember the other end of the spectrum. The country with the highest life expectancy is Japan, over 80 years, and there are nearly no vegetarian Japanese. They just emphasize meat a lot less than Westerners.

I say, balance in everything. I know where Ms Freedman is coming from. In the face of a lot of unreasonable people, it doesn't pay for her to take a reasonable tone. So, even though the dog on the cover seems to go with the title Beg, it is Rory Freedman who is begging, for a hearing among those who do not wish to hear.

Monday, August 26, 2013

Decoding botany

kw: book reviews, nonfiction, botany, nomenclature, dictionaries

Do you think you want to be a botanist? The prime asset to beginning a botanical career is a classical education. That's right, the Trivium (Grammar, Logic and Rhetoric) and the Quadrivium (Arithmetic, Geometry, Music and Astronomy). And Grammar, including both Latin and Greek vocabulary, was traditionally taught in Latin; "grammar" is the study of the Latin rules of sentence construction. In fact, prior to the mid-19th Century, all seven subjects were taught in Latin. This would not be a bad idea today, particularly for anyone entering a biological science.

For those of us who prefer a more glancing acquaintance with formal botany, at least a course or two in Latin and Greek vocabulary would be a big help. Then, if you want just a smattering of "latinate" word knowledge, you would do well to read through Latin for Gardeners: Over 3,000 Plant Names Explained and Explored by Lorraine Harrison. The core of the book is a dictionary listing of the 3,000 or so terms with very brief meanings. For example, a few items from the "F" pages:

fenestralis fen-ESS-tra-lis
fenestralis, fenestrale
With openings like a window, as in Vriesia fenestralis

fibrillosus fy-BRIL-oh-sus
fibrillosa, fibrillosum
fibrosus fy-BROH-sus
fibrosa, fibrosum
Fibrous, as in Dicksonia fibrosa

Certain prefixes are also shown, including

multi-
Used in compound words to denote many

poly-
Used in compound words to denote many

I picked a pair that includes one from Latin and one from Greek; both are used. It would have helped just a bit more if the author noted that multi- is from Latin and poly- is from Greek. A simple L and G in the listing would do. 3,000 of those would not take up much extra space. A regular rule, not always followed, is to use a Latin prefix with a Latin determiner and so with Greek. An example that keeps the rule is polycarpus; -carpus is from Greek for a fruit or seed pod, but originally meant "wrist". Your carpal bones reside in your wrists and the back of your hands. A plant named polycarpus has many fruits.

If this were only a dictionary it would be pretty dry fare. But the author has included biographical notes on 15 "plant hunters" (AKA explorers) and 20 plant genera such as Helianthus and Quercus (sunflower and oak). There is also a small "Latin in Action" blurb every 3-4 pages, and short essays on "plant themes" that include groups of words related to, for example, color or fragrance. I would like to have seen a section just on the prefixes and suffixes, perhaps even a matrix or table showing the many suffixes that go with each prefix, by means of a check mark or block. A big lack is explanation of Genera. Only 20 are described, and Delphinium, for example, is not one of them. How to know the word is derived from "Dolphin"?

All that aside, it is a good book to keep handy for looking up the meaning of a species name. Quercus rubra? Aha! Red oak! If you want to dig deeper into Biological Latin (quite distinct from Classical Latin or the Church Latin all Roman Catholics had to learn until about 1975), a good place to start is this BayGardens article, and the links it contains.

Thursday, August 22, 2013

Genetic byways

kw: book reviews, nonfiction, genetics, essays

It is a rare book in which I learn something from every chapter, but such is The Violinist's Thumb: And Other Lost Tales of Love, War, and Genius as Written by Our Genetic Code, by Sam Kean. At first, I expected a kind of send-up of Stephen Jay Gould's The Panda's Thumb, but not so. Rather, the book is a delightful exploration of some lesser-known stories told with and by DNA, from the pen of a sprightly writer.

The title episode is not a chapter subject, but part of one: Chapter 12 explores the genetics of art, artistic expression and ability, with Niccolò Paganini as the centerpiece. Paganini's short career as a violinist was so remarkable the Catholic church refused to bury him on sanctified ground, suspecting he had a pact with the devil. His promiscuous private life and generally atheistic tendencies didn't help. He was actually inflicted with a genetic defect that left his connective tissues exceptionally loose, thus his fingers, and his left thumb in particular, could perform reaches on the violin's neck that were considered unhuman. While he became the greatest violin virtuoso ever known, he suffered continual illnesses, fragile skin, a shortened career, and an early death (well, not too early: age 58), what some called "payback" for his incredible talent.

Other talents with a genetic link include "perfect pitch", the ability to recognize a note and whether it is exactly in tune. Different sources state that this ability is found in between one and ten persons per 10,000, but is much more prevalent among those who have a close relative or two with perfect pitch. Good relative pitch is more common (perhaps 10% of us): This is the ability to properly tune an instrument such as a guitar or even a piano using a single perfect tone for reference. Until I bought an electronic tuner a few years ago, I tuned instruments using a tuning fork, the 440Hz "A". People with lesser skills can usually tune a guitar if they have a well-tuned one or a piano to compare with ("good relative pitch"). Electronic tuners make it much easier for folks with poorer pitch discrimination to tune a guitar or banjo or mandolin. My grandfather could tune a piano, including the proper "stretch" above and below the middle two octaves, by first tuning the A above Middle C to a 440Hz fork, and going from there.

But not everything is genetically determined. Kean explores epigenetics—which lends partial support to that anathema of natural selection, "inheritance of acquired traits"—and shows how certain life experiences can affect children and even grandchildren and further. Shades of Biblical curses "to the third and fourth generation".

He also reveals the real obstacle to human cloning. Primate ova have a more complex and delicate system of spindle structures that participate in cell division. Removing and replacing the nucleus from a sheep ovum to produce Dolly, and later successes with cats and several other species, depended on extracting the nucleus while leaving the spindle system intact. This is just barely possible (one success in 400 ova, in the case of Dolly) with more robust mammalian ova, but no technique has yet been even imagined that will work for human or ape, or probably even monkey, ova.

The biggest learning for me is that DNA doesn't unwind cleanly when being duplicated or expressed to mRNA. A cluster of enzymes snips one strand of the DNA, lets a bit of unwinding proceed, then re-welds it. This has to happen properly many times for the expression of a single gene, and an untold number of times during mitosis and meiosis, when DNA is totally unspooled and duplicated. I didn't learn whether this snip-weld sequence occurs only on the "copy" strand (the one not being expressed), but I suspect that is the case. I also wonder if it is the same in bacteria…

The big mystery resulting from the Human Genome Project, now a decade in the past, is why humans have so few genes, something like 24,000. It was confidently predicted in the 1990s that we must have 100,000 or more. Known protein-coding segments of our DNA make up only 2% of the 3 billion bases, about 60 million. At least 8% of our total DNA came from viruses, and possibly much, much more. But those and the rest of that 98%, far from being the "junk DNA" that some benighted scientists once sneered at, seem to include a very large "regulatome" (my coining), that not only determines when a "gene" is expressed, but which of several proteins to make from it via RNA editing. The central dogma of genetics—DNA to RNA to unique protein—is now long dead. A protein is now realized to resemble a sentence made from several words, rather than a single long word. Editing gathers a number of components, from one or more "genes", to produce the sentence. This is what turns 24,000 protein coding segments (we need a new term; "gene" is enormously inadequate!) into a few million proteins and peptides.

Genes are not destiny. This is similar to physiology; if you get an "exploratory" CT scan, the radiologist will probably point out between 5 and 15 anomalies. None of them is likely to cause trouble. Some imaging centers, with idle scanner time and a large mortgage to pay on it, advertize things like whole body scans. You know the proverb: look for trouble and you are sure to find some. Many people carry "the gene for" something, but never experience what that something is. And now that you can get your whole genome sequenced for one or two thousand dollars, should you? I say, don't look for trouble unless you have a real reason for doing so, such as three out of four grandparents who died in their 50s of heart attack. Even then, the DNA sequence won't tell you anything new. You still have to eat your veggies, get your weight down, and exercise and maybe you'll survive into your 60s. With different grandparents, perhaps you'd live to your 80s or 90s, but remember Jim Fixx? He was a member of Mensa and a long distance runner who died of a heart attack at age 52. Was that such a shame? Because without all that running and eating well, he'd have died much earlier, like most of his relatives. He did what he could with what he had. That's the most any of us can ask for.

Cause and effect are hard to untangle. People studied Einstein's brain to find if he had something special they could see. He did have an extra-large parietal lobe, which might have helped his genius. But was it inborn (we don't have his parents' brains to compare), or was it because he was an accomplished violinist? Did a big P-lobe make him a better violin player or better scientist, or did his violin playing make him a better cosmologist, P-lobe or no? He thought so. We don't know enough about both genetics and the nurturing of young geniuses to tell, even a little. It'll take decades of study to learn even a little, and perhaps we would be the poorer for it, rather than for the better.

A song chorus I wrote in 1996 says, "We are dealt the cards, but our own hand we play". This could be a theme for half the chapters in this book. What we think we know is still just a trifle compared to what there is to know.

Sunday, August 11, 2013

A philosophy of illusion

kw: book reviews, nonfiction, philosophy, surveys

John Gray probably didn't set out to survey the field of philosophy when he began writing The Silence of Animals: On Progress and Other Modern Myths. But in the end, he surveyed the field pretty well. The book's title comes from an extended quote by Max Picard, which begins, "The silence of animals is different from the silence of men." The excerpt goes on to speak of the "heavy" silence of animals, "like stone." Gray quotes Picard only to disagree with him, focusing instead on the human desire for silence that cannot be achieved, because we are so noisy inside.

I wonder if silence-seeking has any hold at all on the modern generations. It seems there is no ear upon the street that does not have an earbud stuffed into it. I was recently asked by a young friend why I am never seen listening to music. I replied, "I have a constant sound track running in my head." She nodded thoughtfully, knowingly: I am a songwriter, though I am not prolific, and it takes me years to write a single song. Regardless, there is music enough in me to fill many lifetimes. Perhaps the inner sound track of most folks is not so melodious as mine, and must be drowned out with the contents of one's iPod.

But Gray's point is not silence or its lack anyway. It is to show that progress is a myth we must tell ourselves in order to have a reason for going on. Perhaps the couch potatoes have it right. Perhaps they realize, dimly though they may see, that passively taking it all in is better than the "striving after the wind" of which Solomon wrote.

In three long chapters that weave together 20-plus threads, Gray demonstrates from every angle that we cannot live without myths, because the intake of our senses is so illusory. He rightly notes that science represents our striving to extend our senses and make them more reliable. Thus, to replace our feeling that this thing is warmer or cooler than the other, we have a series of thermometers that cover various ranges from absolute zero upward, even to the thousands or millions of degrees (or more) that exist (thankfully) in distant spaces. He cares little for science, and equally little for experience. It is hard to determine just what he might be, as I find no positive statement in the book.

Reading it motivated me to gather a short list of the "more major" philosophical trends, selected only in that they could be distinguished from one another in my own mind:
  • Presocratic philosophy (actually, there were several, but they get lumped as one these days)
  • Academical philosophy
  • Cynicism
  • Stoicism
  • Scepticism
  • Neoplatonism
  • Christian
  • Scholasticism
  • Rationalism
  • Empiricism
  • Idealism
  • Solipsism
  • Liberalism
  • Evolutionism (biology is just the tip of the iceberg)
  • Pragmatism
  • Materialism
  • Existentialism
  • Postmodernism AKA Logical Positivism
  • "New Scientific" philosophy
To which I would add that branch of rationalism I call "sensibilism". I judge things by "is that sensible?" To some it may represent a merger of existentialism with logical positivism, in that "sensible" can mean "of the senses" equally as "making sense logically". It has been fashionable for 50+ years, when any discussion gets too deep and people disagree, particularly if religion or politics were brought up, for someone to say, "Well, I have my own philosophy." Taken to its logical end, this means there are actually some 7 billion philosophies out there, which means philosophy is an illusion also. Ha! Thought so.

I came away from the book with less than I had when I began, but that seems to be the author's intent.

Wednesday, August 07, 2013

The Psychopath Factory

kw: book reviews, nonfiction, cults, escapees

I really wish this book were fiction: Beyond Belief: My Secret Life Inside Scientology and My Harrowing Escape by Jenna Miscavige Hill. I really wish it were fiction, but it is not. Born into a Scientology family, at age six or seven Jenna was separated from her parents so they could—"for the greater good of humanity"—work a grueling schedule on church staff. Her parents were trusted with great responsibility, at least in part because her father is the older brother of David Miscavige, the leader of all of Scientology since the death of L. Ron Hubbard in 1986.

For the first eight years or so, she thought she was living a normal life, though she didn't like it much. She was one of a couple hundred kids who were raised at The Ranch in the California desert. A small contingent of adults managed the older kids, who supervised the younger ones, and all (except the adults) quite literally slaved to clean up the rundown buildings and landscape the grounds. As one of the youngest, Jenna could do little hard physical labor, so she became a kind of medic (with some sort of 3-letter-acronym title) to the rest. She cleaned and bandaged scrapes and cuts, dispensed aspirin and other medicines. While her parents were stationed comparatively nearby in Hemet, California, she saw them one or two times per month. Later, her mother was sent to Florida ("Flag", the headquarters of Sea Org, the training center for the most dedicated staff). Her father was busier and busier, and some years she saw them no more than once, usually at Christmas. The long separation led to marital troubles, and her mother had an affair, which landed her in RPF, the Scientology prison camp for Sea Org sinners. Not long after her parents were reunited, they left Scientology, and were "declared" SP's or Suppressive Persons. Think of Excommunication on steroids. Offered a chance to leave with them, Jenna declined. Jenna was 16. She and they had no contact for at least a couple of years.

Did you ever hear the proverb about the fly living in a vinegar bottle? Never tasted sugar, and doesn't know it exists. Such is the ingrown world of a powerful cult. Although Jenna had begun to realize she didn't have to doubt herself all the time, it took her another 8 years to get to the point that she felt she had to leave. By this time, she was married, and she and her husband tried to go through the church-accepted "exit" procedure because he didn't want them to be "declared" and thus lose contact with his relatives. The process was so grueling and invasive, she eventually refused to continue, and after much sturm und drang, now with her husband's full support, the two of them fled.

Reading the book, I wonder how she retained her sanity. Her experiences were an exercise in systematic production of insanity, from which she gradually, miraculously, recovered. The Scientology mind control system was carefully thought out and finely honed by Hubbard, who by 1950 had already become very rich from writing science fiction. In SF circles, he was a World Builder, capable of imagining a complete and consistent world, and rendering it in a narrative that draws the reader into its imaginary milieu. Dianetics and the books and lectures that followed as he built the "church" of Scientology became Hubbard's tour de force of world building, a consistent all-encompassing system of mind control that, had he known about it, Mao Zedong would have co-opted.

I've observed Scientology, mostly from a distance, for over 45 years. I was in my late teens when I read parts of Dianetics. I didn't read it all, because it was all hype with asserted "proofs" but nothing a fellow could substantiate. I had my first direct contact with Scientology in 1968, when someone at work invited me to a lecture. There was some kind of illustration, with about 8 items arrayed up a ladder, with a Buddha-like figure at the top. After a short introduction, most of the "lecture" consisted of an explanation of each of the 8 points (such as "Group Survival", a couple of steps above a more self-oriented point), then asking in the audience for a show of hands, who "understands" the point. After that, asking for another show of hands, who believed they had "internalized" the point. I don't recall what the last point is, something about wholeness and all of humanity, but I still had my hand up. The moderator directed a quizzical look my way. I said, "I am a Christian. When someone becomes a child of God, that comes as a gift. It is where we start, and we go onward from there." I noted shock, followed by rather murderous looks on a few faces, so I stood and slipped out of there. To my relief, the fellow at work didn't contact me after that.

Unbeknownst to me, a few years later a close relative I'll call Jason became involved with Scientology and began "auditing". I don't know how he paid for it, because auditing is expensive. It is a 1-on-1 process with an auditor and an "E-Meter", a klutzy kind of lie detector (a sensitive resistivity meter attached to a pair of soup cans you hold in your hands). The auditor questions a subject, watching the needle of the meter, and helps them get rid of "engrams" (this is a real psychological term, but isn't closely related to the way Scientologists use the term). The goal is to get rid of all engrams and become "clear". In about 1970 it was reported that getting "clear" cost about $10,000. If auditing costs have risen at the same rate as a loaf of bread, the cost today is about $60,000. Of course, if getting everyone "clear" were the only goal, things would stop there. But there are 8 steps of something called "OT" (for Operating Thetan) after that, at absurdly high cost. People who are having a hard time paying for all this are offered staff positions. Scientology staff members (Jason was one for a number of years) work on projects and get free room and board plus a bit of money (it was $15 per month in the 1970s) in return for free auditing.

Nobody is perfect, so new problems that arise in people's lives need to be cleared with further auditing. Auditing for staff is more arduous, and is actually a kind of brainwashing torture. Someone who gets to their wits' end and acts out beyond some limit can get RPF time. Jason was in RPF for a while, perhaps close to the average "sentence" of 2 years. Later, his father helped him pay some hoked-up debt he had, and got free of Scientology for a while. Today, nearing age 60, he runs a small business, but has on-and-off business relationships with members of Scientology. I suppose he is a "public Scientologist" now, the kind that pays for any auditing and other services he receives. He certainly makes more than $15 a month! We talk from time to time, but nothing about Scientology any more. He is still under their spell of unrelenting positivity about everything to do with Scientology. He may have private dissenting thoughts, but you'd never know it.

Read the book. You'll see for yourself how terrifyingly thorough their brainwashing techniques are. The ideal Scientologist is a perfect psychopath. Able to totally fool a lie detector, because he or she is in total control of all emotions, including familial ones. Family can be discarded (as Jenna was) to further the mission. Everything, but Everything is subservient to the goals of the organization. Power over lesser staff is exercised pitilessly and thoroughly. Jason is the only member of my extended family who has had daily acquaintance with handguns (outside the military)...or needed to. A cadre of Scientology operatives are the only group that ever raided an FBI office (to destroy documents about Scientology) and got away with it. Jenna M. Hill was one of the lucky ones, someone who cannot be manufactured into a psychopath. Someone with a conscience.

Sunday, August 04, 2013

Getting doctors to be doctors again

kw: book reviews, medicine, doctors, advice

There is a strong parallel between medicine and religion. Even more, the contrast between "doctoring" and genuine medical practice is like that between religion and faith. My favorite proverb about religion is
The core of religion is a checklist. You can hang it on the wall. A robot could perform the checklist perfectly. You cannot.
This is why I say that my faith is not a religion. Faith is a divine relationship; religion is a specified practice. What about doctoring? Doctors today make explicit use of checklists, which they often call "pathways", to "work up" a patient who comes to them with a particular "chief complaint". A wry joke going around is, to get seen quickly in an emergency room, when you tell the receptionist why you are there, make sure that you mention your chest hurts. Of course, that means you'll be there at least 24 hours and spend an extra $10,000.

If you actually try this, you will find yourself on the "Chest Pain Pathway", which involves a series of tests, including a CT scan, and an overnight stay for "observation". If you don't actually have any chest pain, you will still have a hell of a time getting off the pathway. There are hundreds (thousands?) of such "pathways".

The modern doctor will listen to you only for a few seconds, until you say something that triggers one of the pathways. If 10-15 seconds pass and no pathway is yet identified, the doctor will interrupt you with a series of questions, always of the yes/no variety. Once you mention the "right words" that trigger a pathway, even in passing, more yes/no questions follow, and pretty soon the doctor will stand and say "we'll do a couple of tests" while heading for the door. Less than a minute will have passed. If you happen to be a rambling storyteller, particularly if you are under great stress and confusion, you may not yet have talked about the real reason you are there! But now you are on a pathway, and you may never get off it (because you may die, or be sent home with "no finding").

It is estimated that at least 100,000 people die in U.S. hospitals due to "misdiagnosis". In most cases, it would be more accurate to say they died without a diagnosis, because they were killed by the hunt for one.

To literally save your life, you first have to do everything you can to stay off one of these pathways, because here's the dirty secret. A pathway is designed to minimize the chances you will sue the doctor, or at least make it very unlikely that you could win a malpractice lawsuit. They are NOT designed to lead to a diagnosis. But, it is becoming apparent that pathways themselves are a kind of malpractice.

Drs. Leana Wen and Joshua Kosowsky call this "cookbook medicine". I call it "robot medicine". A robot can do it; you don't need a doctor for that (look up "Symptom checker" and try the one at WebMD, for example). Robot medicine is a practice of "ruling out", and you'll hear a doctor say, "This may be a heart attack," (you mentioned chest pain) or, "We have to rule out a cranial hemorrhage" (you used the words "worst headache"). Drs. Wen and Kosowsky have written When Doctors Don't Listen: How to Avoid Misdiagnoses and Unnecessary Tests to help you and me learn to stay off such pathways and drive a doctor to diagnosis.

Another proverb you probably know: To a man with a hammer, everything looks like a nail. The very availability of CT scanners, and the readiness of insurance companies to pay for CT scans, means that scanners are massively overused. Ditto for MRI and PET and other scanners, and for increasingly specific (and costly) blood tests. Excess CT scans are particularly worrisome, because even the most modern, low-dose scan exposes you to 500-1,000 times the radiation of an old-fashioned X-ray. ER's ought to have a chart on the wall:
  • Got chest pain? Prepare for an overnight stay, 3-4 blood draws and a CT scan. Equivalent radiation dose (ERD): 400 chest X-rays.
  • Terrible headache? 2 blood draws and a CT scan of the head. ERD 500 dental X-rays.
  • Abdominal pain with diarrhea? Prepare to spend the night, plus 3 blood draws, a sigmoidoscopy [actually a good idea!] and an abdominal CT scan. ERD 600 X-rays.
And so forth. Just for grins, if the radiologist has any trouble reading the CT scan, or notices any anomaly, you'll get a second CT scan (or if you are lucky an MRI scan: there is no radiation), with a different IV of contrast "stuff". Many folks are allergic to the contrast injection, such as my wife, who is allergic to both media that are used for kidney X-rays. Meaning she can never have another X-ray looking for kidney problems.

Properly used, CT scans save lives. But they come with a known risk: a 1-2% increase in the chance of getting cancer after 20 years or so. If, as some contend, 98-99% of CT scans are unnecessary, then it is a wash, a life lost to cancer for every life saved.

In the past it was not so. An early chapter of the book traces medical history over the past 20 centuries. Of the four stages of medical practice, the third may have been the best. From the time of Pasteur and Koch, and into the early era of antibiotics, doctors were very diligent to get a good "history" from a patient, plus they had a growing number of effective remedies, both medicines and surgical techniques. Prior to the 1960's, diagnosis was king. The most effective doctors had a quality known as Augenblick (German for "eye blink"). My uncle's father was one such. He could diagnose many, many conditions at a glance, yet he always took time to hear what the patient said (or the person who brought the patient in, if the patient was unconscious). The history might modify the eyeblink diagnosis. He took nothing for granted, but also had enormous common sense. If a patient arrived at the hospital with a note from him, the doctors there knew the diagnosis was a good one.

Diagnosis is still king, but the king is in hiding. Doctors practice defensive medicine, particularly in the ER. This consists not in driving to a diagnosis, but in "ruling out" rare conditions that could lead to a lawsuit if they are missed. The way a good entry interview ought to go is simple. You tell your story and the doctor listens to all of it. If you aren't a good storyteller (some doctors use the disparaging term "poor historian", but such doctors ought to go be plumbers or something), the doctor will ask questions to move the story along; preferably, questions not of the yes/no variety. At some point, the doctor will have a short list of possible diagnoses. The questions that follow are designed to distinguish among these competing diagnoses. This is called differential diagnosis. At some point, one idea is the most likely, and this is the working diagnosis (sometimes there will still be two, and that may be the actual case, that you have two things wrong at once). A good doctor won't just do all this in his head, but will discuss the possibilities with you, and will tell you the working diagnosis, or perhaps the last two possible diagnoses, with suggestions for making a final distinction. Only then can effective treatment begin.

It helps to learn to be a better storyteller. Consider chest pain. It is sure to trigger a "chest pain pathway", unless you first mention that you helped your cousin move yesterday, and carried one end of her piano. If you can also press a finger to one spot, saying, "It hurts the most right there", you have a chance of knocking your doctor off the pathway, and getting appropriate help for a pulled muscle in your chest. If not, you could be swept along with the momentum of the pathway, and go home a day or two later, with a CT scan or two under your belt and at least 3 fresh needle sticks. And, nothing for your pulled muscle.

The word "doctor" means "teacher". Prior to "modern medicine", a doctor taught all her patients how to recognize what symptoms meant, and what to do about it. Doctors didn't ask yes/no questions until late in the process, to distinguish provisional diagnoses from one another. During the history-taking phrase, the questions were open-ended, intended to get every scrap of information you could deliver.

To help your doctor arrive at the right diagnosis, and thus to treat you for the right condition, these days you have to help out, a lot! To this end, Drs. Wen and Kosowsky spend half the book training us to use their "8 Pillars to Better Diagnosis":
  1. Tell your whole story. This means making sure the doctor gets it all, particularly that which worries you the most (don't let embarrassment hold you back; tell it all). And don't answer yes or no to yes/no questions; use them as a springboard to tell more of your story. When the doctor interrupts, interrupt right back (as nicely as you can).
  2. Assert yourself into the doctor's thought process. I'd have used the word "insert", but the authors are emphasizing that you have to be assertive, almost pushy, to keep the doctor collaborating with you.
  3. Participate in the physical exam. Of course, show the doctor "where it hurts", so to speak, but also ask what he is thinking. Ask for jargon words to be explained.
  4. Make the differential diagnosis together. Ask for the doctor's list of ideas. If none make sense, say so and ask, "What else could this be?" The initial net needs to be broad, but seek a balance. 100 vague possibilities are not a differential diagnosis.
  5. Partner for the decision making process. Continue to ask how this or that possibility can be most simply eliminated, or how any one could be confirmed.
  6. Apply tests rationally. Don't agree to "ruling out" tests for low-probability conditions unless your doctor can make a good case why every symptom you have described fits that condition, and none of them in themselves make it less likely. Be sure you understand what every test is meant to distinguish or determine.
  7. Use common sense to confirm a working diagnosis. The visit is not over without a working diagnosis. But it has to make sense.
  8. Integrate the diagnosis into the healing process. The doctor must tell you what to expect from the treatment she prescribes or recommends, and how it relates to the diagnosis. The working diagnosis may not have been the right one, so knowing what to expect can clue you in that something isn't quite right.
Nobody will remember these points during an ER visit, or even an office visit, so one third of the book consists of exercises and practices to help you get very familiar with the process. No longer can you and I afford to passively "let the doctor do the doctoring", because we will almost always find ourselves being pushed toward one of the "pathways". These pathways are not helpful to you, but to the doctor's malpractice insurance carrier. Throughout, the authors stress that we must be respectful with the doctor, not confrontational, because, after all, we went to him for his help, and such help will be harder to elicit if we offend him. If your doctor is thin-skinned and arrogant, do everything you can to change doctors.

My most important take-away from this book is a question that I need to ask: "Doctor, what will this test determine? What is the diagnosis you wish it to confirm?" If the doctor intends to "rule out" something, don't agree to it. Demand (nicely) a differential diagnosis, and ask where the test fits into that.

I am in the process of getting a new doctor. A couple weeks ago my wife made an appointment for me (shoulder strain) with my primary care physician. John is a good doctor, one who listens much better than most, and we've developed a good working relationship. But a week later, his office called to say that he had retired, there is now a new doctor taking over the practice, and did I still want the appointment? Well, what choice do I have? Now that I am on Medicare, it is hard to find a doctor who will take a new patient. I accepted the appointment. Now I have a new doctor to train. I'll make copies of the relevant parts of WDDL and study up, so when I see him a couple days from now, I can start off on a good footing and gain an appropriate collaborative relationship.