Monday, November 16, 2026

To avoid flirting with death

 kw: book reviews, nonfiction, medicine, risks, emergency medicine, prevention

This is long, brace yourself. The TLDR version:

Reading 99 Ways to Die: And How to Avoid Them by Ashely Alker, MD, triggered many memories. A little bit of what follows reviews the book; much more recounts fifteen incidents and matters that interest me:

  1. Necrotizing Fasciitis, experienced by one of my closest friends.
  2. Doxycycline and antibiotic resistance.
  3. Testing for what can and cannot kill.
  4. Polio.
  5. The 1918 flu.
  6. Assigned at birth?
  7. LSD.
  8. Cyanide.
  9. Carbon Monoxide.
  10. Fufu (pufferfish) sushi.
  11. Longevity before antibiotics.
  12. Tornadoes.
  13. Earthquakes.
  14. Altitude sickness.
  15. Radiation.

The closing paragraph of the book is a brief list of "how to avoid death" tips, including, "When using a table saw, ensure there is a safety stop", "Never ignore chest pain", "Get a carbon monoxide detector", "Don't run in an earthquake", and "Get your vaccines."

Get this book, it's worth a read, right through, and it is worth keeping handy. It is, interestingly enough, enjoyable reading. The author has a dry sense of humor. Sadly, the book lacks an index, which would make it much more useful.

Now let's get down to business. Dr. Alker is an Emergency Medicine physician. Should you pop in to the right emergency department, she's the doctor who you will meet first once they bring you in from the waiting room. Chest pain, or active bleeding? The wait won't be long. Other issues? There is no telling; it depends on how many chest pain or open wound cases are ahead of you. Before the doctor sees you a Triage nurse evaluates how likely you are to die in the next few minutes or hours. The first priority is to stop death. When they run out of imminent death cases, everyone else is treated in the order of severity, worst to least (When my wife sucked a vitamin pill into her lung, we gave up after waiting six hours and went home. By then in had probably dissolved in the lung).

There aren't exactly 99 chapters because some deal with multiple things. But there are a lot of chapters, in thirteen sections, beginning with Infections and ending with Warfare, from anthrax as a bio-weapon to nuclear warfare. As you may imagine, "avoid" becomes a very flexible term.

I'll give an illustration. Eight years ago my car was totaled. It was the most unavoidable accident I can imagine. In the early morning I was on my way to meet someone, waiting for a stoplight to change, and stationary about a car length back from the white line that I usually creep right up to. No car was behind me. In the intersection ahead a car turned left into oncoming traffic and was hit, which catapulted a Jeep into my car. I just had time to take my foot off the brake. That one action reduced the force of the crash by half because my car could move, but it increased the jerk upon myself. However, I was belted in and had no injuries. When you're sitting still and the accident comes to you, that is pretty unavoidable! What might have made it totally avoidable? Sleeping later that morning. Then I'd never have known I avoided it, except perhaps in later news reports. In other cases, "avoid" requires a bit of forethought, so as not to dance with death (the illustration is from 1916, "The German Tango" by Louis Raemaekers).

A year ago I called my closest friend, who lives out West, to invite him to the 50th Anniversary party for my wife and me. I found he had just been released from three months in the hospital! He had been treated in Seattle for Necrotizing Fasciitis, or "flesh eating bacteria" in his leg. The leg had been saved, but he could not walk yet. We went to see him and his wife a few weeks ago; he walks quite well now, even though half the musculature of that leg is missing, but it is slowly growing back. Was avoidance possible (they were in eastern Washington visiting family there)? Wading in a stream warmed by the sun exposed him to the organism. A colder stream would have been wiser, but who thinks of that? Other good advice about this disease is found in the first chapter of the book, pp 7-9. Other bacterial afflictions range from strep throat (yes, it can kill) to leprosy.

A number of bacterial infections are discussed under "Superbugs" and the author writes of her favorite antibiotic, doxycycline, on p 19. The tetracyclines in general, including tetracycline and minocycline, are also favorites of mine, because of arthritis. I used to have rheumatoid arthritis, but I don't any more. That is because many, perhaps most, cases of rheumatoid arthritis are not primarily autoimmune disease but are a consequence of a battle between your immune system and a species of bacterium called Mycoplasma that is encapsulated in a joint, or a few joints. I was treated with tetracycline for three years, which in my case was sufficient to rid my joints of the organism. That was more than twenty years ago. My father, who began treatment later in the progress of the disease—at age 60 he could hardly walk, but by age 70, still being treated, he could walk well—had to battle various doctors as he outlived one after another, because each new doctor wanted him to stop the prescription. He would have none of it. His mother had been killed by a series of overdoses of Indocin, which is only a symptomatic treatment that gets less effective over time; neither she nor Dad nor any doctors they knew had any knowledge of the tetracycline treatment then. So this is the 100th way to die: sometimes your doctor does it. If you read the word "Iatrogenic", it means "doctor-caused."

On page 39 the author speaks of being uninterested in anything "that can't kill you." I kind of understand her view. Dealing with chronic pain, for example, is frustrating for everyone involved. But I wish the doctor I had in early 2000 was interested in first ruling out deadly things. I had pain for months, and this passive doctor tried an ulcer med, then an antibiotic, until I got frustrated enough to forge a referral to a gastroenterologist and get a colonoscopy. I had colon cancer, and I was only days from death when the doctor called ahead to the hospital for me and said I should go to the emergency room. I was put in the hospice and given IV feeding for 3 days to build me up to endure the operation. Obviously, it was a success. I thank God for a surgeon and a few other doctors who were more aggressive than my family doctor (whom I replaced immediately!). Now my watchword is, "Get your eyes on the prize" and "rule out deadly stuff first." I'll be getting my fifteenth colonoscopy in a couple of weeks…

The second section of the book deals with diseases that vaccines can prevent or mitigate, including polio (pp 61-65). I was a second- and third-grader in a private school in Salt Lake City in the early 1950s when Dr. Jonas Salk was creating the first polio vaccines (three of them). My schoolmates and I all had numerous injections, by very friendly nurses who would do things like paint Mickey Mouse on our arms with Mercurochrome (a danger in itself, but who knew in 1952?). When the results of the testing were published, and the vaccines were released, my name was one of 25,000 children's names in the newspaper, as a "got the real stuff" experimental subject, and an equal number of kids who had the Placebo (weak salt water). The irony is, at age 19 months I had already had polio, but it wasn't recognized at the time. Years later, a doctor looked at my twisted leg with the smaller foot and made the retrospective diagnosis. During my early teens, by diligent "coercion" of my leg, I straightened out my walk. Bones respond to persistent pressure.

Starting at age 65 (now I'm 79) I have taken the flu shot each year in October. Earlier in life, on three occasions I had the seasonal flu, I could throw it off in a day. But not in the late 1990's when I was about forty. My mother had sent me the family stamp collections, particularly including her mother's collection. My grandmother was single until age 25 (late for that generation), and passed her time collecting stamps from everyone in the neighborhood. During World War I, she collected thousands of stamps, and she left most of them on pieces of the envelopes. She kept American stamps in a big stock book, and overseas stamps in another stock book, right through the war and for a few years after, until she had two children. There were hundreds of stamps from 1918, nearly all on paper. I soaked them off in batches using warm water. Then I got sick. I was bedridden with a horrible cough, high fever, muscle aches, headache that came and went, and great weakness, for five days. I wonder if it is possible that I reactivated virus particles of the 1918 "Spanish" flu, and became its latest victim? (Well, almost victim, because I didn't quite die) The author's discussion of the 1918 flu begins on page 80.

The next point isn't a disease but a complaint. On page 101, having used the term "male", the author has a footnote, "Referring to a person assigned male at birth." A doctor can't afford to be this afflicted with Wokeness. Sex isn't "assigned" at birth, it is discovered, if it has not already been discovered during an ultrasound or by a blood test. Sex is biological, immutable, no matter what hormone treatments or surgery a person may later undergo in order to create an "identity" as a different "gender". Don't call me a transphobe. I don't fear trans people (and I know a few), I just think they are stupid and with proper, gentle support, will usually outgrow it. End of soapbox rant.

The Drugs section of the book deals with both medications and recreational drugs, including LSD. During "the Sixties" I was involved with drug addicts, fortunately in a small way. But I did happen to witness a young girl having a rather bad LSD trip try to climb out a third-story window. Those of us there with her prevented her suicide; whether from a delusion or intentional, I didn't find out. So even though we read on page 190 that LSD can't kill directly, the indirect effects can indeed be deadly. Leave psychedelics alone. They have permanent effects and a bad trip can arrive "out of nowhere" months or years later.

Cyanide! Now things get personal. Also in the late 1960's I was attending college as a 7th year Senior (that can happen when you work your way through, and also take way too many "elective" courses just out of interest). Members of SDS, a radical group of the time, had frequent antiwar protests on campus. I was of the "America: Love it or Leave it" sort, and apparently a rather effective heckler. One day after a protest I returned to my car, fortunately from the downwind side. I smelled a hint of bitter almonds. I'd taken several chemistry courses, and in one we were given whiffs of a number of smelly chemicals. I recognized the smell. I backed off, held my breath, and then opened the car doors to air it out. Hydrogen cyanide, HCN, is a light gas, about 7% lighter than air, so it rises and slowly wafts away. It's a good thing none of the SDS guys had a gun… Thereafter, I parked in a different location every day.

The saddest circumstance of my life was losing a valued co-worker and all his family to carbon monoxide. They weren't raised in America and had no idea of the dangers of this scentless, deadly gas. They were living in South Dakota and planned to take a weekend trip to Denver, eight hours to the south. It was winter. He was tuning up his car and started the engine, in a closed garage, to set the timing. He passed out almost immediately. His wife smelled fumes coming into the kitchen and opened the garage door. She collapsed where she stood. The children were upstairs asleep. Friends who came by the next morning noticed that the garage door windows were blackened. By then the car was out of gas. The dangers of this gas need to be taught in school, preferably in elementary grades, and probably more than once. The Poison section of the book has more to say on pp 240-242.

My wife is Japanese. We enjoy sushi. Can you guess what comes next? Fortunately, after her father introduced me to sushi (made with tuna and eel), she told me about fugu, or pufferfish. She said several people die every year. I later learned that about fifty are sickened; apparently part of its appeal, besides being delicious, is when it is prepared by an expert who uses just a tiny bit of the dangerous parts so you get a tingly buzz. The amount needed to progress from buzz to funeral isn't much. Not many non-Japanese know that most sushi is made without any fish at all. Mostly vegetables and various mushrooms. Sushi is really "stuff served in or on rice and seaweed, with wasabi (hot radish) and ginger on the side". Sometimes that "stuff" is sashimi, which is fish. Some types of fish are served raw, but most fish and all shellfish such as shrimp are cooked. It takes an expert chef to get all the worms out. There are usually some. For most folks that's a bigger danger as long as they avoid fugu, which is in the Food section on pp 270-271. The poison in fugu is tetrodotoxin, which is also found in some poison dart frogs and the blue-ringed octopus.

A chapter on Time in the section on The Elements starts, "In 1900, world life expectancy was thirty-two years…". This statement is misleading without context. Childhood diseases killed many infants and toddlers. In old cemeteries we've visited (genealogy, don't you know), it seems that half the tombstones are half-size, sometimes for babies that weren't even named, just "Baby Johnson". A youngster who survived to the age of five in 1900 had an average life expectancy in the late sixties. Two societal changes doubled and then almost tripled overall life expectancy since 1920 or so: cleaning up water systems, "miracle drugs" such as antibiotics, and vaccines. My mother had scarlet fever at age ten and almost died. Before her, my father's mother had scarlet fever at age twelve. My brothers and I, all born between 1945 and 1955, had measles, mumps, and chicken pox. Fortunately, there were already vaccines for smallpox, rubella (German measles), tetanus, and diphtheria. The polio vaccines came out when I was in grade school. I was lucky to contract it so young (before age 2), when it is seldom paralytic. But the point of this Time chapter is that if nothing else kills you, your body will wear out, unevenly, so that some vital organ will go first, and that will be that. We can postpone death, but not totally avoid it.

Now for some fun stuff. The chapter after Time is Tornadoes. I have seen tornadoes in four states. Just a few days ago one came through Bear, Delaware, about 20 miles from our house, and right across the street of some good friends of ours. For nine years we lived in Stillwater, Oklahoma, at the south end of a 40 mile stretch of road that goes to Ponca City (where I worked), and that bit of road is the buckle of the tornado belt. One day I almost drove into a tornado. Oklahoma twisters are frequently rain-wrapped so you can't see them coming. But when rain turns to hail, you know you are in danger. All I could do was turn off and duck the car behind a supermarket. I tuned to a Tulsa station, which was reporting, "We have it on radar. It just crossed [two street names]. That intersection was just on the other side of the building I was hiding behind! Five minutes later, there was blue sky, hail all over the ground, and as I continued driving home, I saw the roof of a restaurant sitting in the schoolyard, and nothing of the restaurant standing but the walk-in freezer. The next day, on the way to work, I saw the remains of an auto beside the road. It was mashed to the point that the proverb made sense: "Get out of your car and lie down. When the tornado is finished with your car, there won't be enough room inside for you."

I have lived in California three times, and one stretch was eleven years. What was I thinking! I experienced several earthquakes, one of which rolled me right out of bed at 6am. A professor at my graduate school in South Dakota said, "Visiting southern California is like walking in front of a loaded crossbow. Living there is like being tied to a chair with the crossbow aimed at you." 'Nuff said about that.

A couple of chapters later, Altitude Sickness is discussed (pp 329-332). I have big lungs, and I've never been bothered by it. My wife and I went, in two days time, from Anaheim, California to Denver, Colorado, and then we went up to the tundra section of Rocky Mountain National Park, at 12,000 feet. Neither she nor I experienced distress, but our car barely made it. Once we settled in at Rapid City a couple days later, I had it retuned for the 3,000 foot elevation of that area. My avoidance method? The right genes, I suppose. Plus my wife and I are both active and she was an athlete before she knew me.

Finally, radiation. Not as much was known about it when I was a boy. At age 11 I was with a group of Boy Scouts who toured a Uranium processing plant in Utah. We were each given a gelatin capsule containing a gram of uranium oxide ("yellowcake"). We all popped it into our pockets. I carried mine around for a day or two, then put it in a dresser drawer. I don't know if getting cancer 45 years later is related or not. More recently, we found that the Radon level in our basement is high. We spent a couple of thousand dollars to get a "mitigation system" installed. We lived here 30 years already… Oh, and the uranium "pill"? I gave it to a Geochemistry professor when I was in college. He was thrilled. By 1970, obtaining uranium, even for scientific use, was practically impossible. I like to think my "A" was earned, but I suppose the gift didn't hurt!

There you have it. Fifteen items, and perhaps twelve that could have proved injurious, while one nearly finished me off. As I wrote above, this book is well worth having on hand.

No comments: