Showing posts with label evil. Show all posts
Showing posts with label evil. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 27, 2026

Evil is as evil does

 kw: book reviews, nonfiction, mini-biographies, evil men, evil

In Dante's Inferno, most murderers are found in the seventh circle of Hell, swimming in a river of boiling blood. A special class of those who betrayed their families, usually by murder and headed up by Cain, are found in the ninth circle, frozen into the ice that imprisons Satan. In Gustave Doré's woodcut, Dante and Virgil are seen walking among them over the ice.

Caligula is not mentioned in Inferno, possibly because he was such a prolific sinner, possibly the "Renaissance man" of sinfulness, that Dante didn't know where to place him. In the book Confronting Evil: Assessing the Worst of the Worst, Bill O'Reilly places Caligula first in the long line of the most evil men in all history, primarily because he is first in time. Along with his coauthor Josh Hammer, O'Reilly limns the lives, and deaths, of fifteen of "the Worst" in twelve chapters, with just a bit of editorial comment. The details of their lives provide sufficient comment.

Among those who lived more recently, most have been called The Antichrist, but so far none has proven to be that personage. Actually, the word "antichrist" is never used in Revelation. The apostle John used this word four times in his first epistle, and once in the second, referring to "deceivers" who deny that Jesus is the Messiah, who deny "the Father and the Son", and deny Jesus Christ "coming in the flesh." The word used by John in Revelation can be translated either "wild beast" or "monster". It is much stronger than the ordinary word for a "beast of the field" such as a lion. I prefer to call this person the Monster. This Monster's career is outlined in Daniel 7, 8 and 11 and Revelation chapters 11 through 20.

Confronting Evil was written with the background of growing numbers of people who try to say that good and evil are matters of opinion, that there is no "objective evil". That is a senseless opinion, and these evil men prove it. Further, there are many today who complain that "religion" is evil, and point to the Crusades. Let it be known clearly that the odd phenomenon of the Crusades was in no way based on any truth in the Bible, and was contrary to Christian faith in every way.

The great murderers of the Twentieth Century were all atheists, with one exception. From the top down, by body count: Mao Zedong, directly responsible for 80-120 million murders; Joseph Stalin, 40-60 million; Adolph Hitler, about 25 million; Pol Pot (not mentioned in the book), 3 million; and the one religious man, Ayatollah Khomeini, between half a million and two million. The great murderer of the current Century (so far) is Vladimir Putin, with a body count pushing two million Russians and Ukrainians. One could argue that the Ukrainians killed Putins' soldiers, but it was at Putin's order that they were put in harm's way, so they are counted against him.

It makes for rough reading. I worship the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, Who is a Living God, and calls His people to abundant Life. He counts Death as "the last enemy." I need to shelter under His wings to be swept out of the presence of death.

I have sometimes considered composing an essay on "the Totalitarian Impulse," which I take as the root of the deepest evil. We all have a desire to control things, to achieve the greatest satisfaction and comfort with no frustration or sadness. Paul wrote to Timothy that "the love of money is a root of all evils," but behind that is the craving for power – for of what use is a pile of money without the power to use it for your own ends? I count as fearsomely evil any person who thinks he or she has the "right" to usurp anyone else's decision-making. Naturally, we must make most decisions for our offspring when they are small, but a huge part of our maturity is learning to release them to make their own decisions as they grown to adulthood. Some parents never learn it. Some persons take the same lack of self control into the way they treat people they supervise, or companies they may lead, or in the worst cases, nations they may gain power over. Of such are those presented in this book.

I hate to detract from this very valuable book, but I must mention that it is marred by great overuse of the historical present. Using "is" tenses rather than "was" tenses is useful to carry a historical narrative along, but there are situations where it is not appropriate, particularly in footnotes and endnotes, and I conclude that the authors haven't learned that yet.

Wednesday, November 20, 2013

Does the Devil know he is evil?

kw: book reviews, nonfiction, psychology, evil, villains

The title of this post is a question I like to ask people when the subject of evil comes up. Think of the great villains of history, distant and recent: Athaliah (a genuine evil queen: see 2Kings 11), Herod, Nero, Caligula, Pope Boniface VIII (who "came in like a fox, reigned like a lion, and died like a dog"), Catherine the Great, Lizzie Borden, Hitler, Mao, Stalin or Osama bin Laden. With the possible exception of Ms Borden, each of these persons, and a great many other "meanies", was convinced he or she was good. There's a Crip hit man who wrote the book Monster while in prison. It is his nickname. He likes it. Most of the book is an attempt to convince the reader that he is really a good guy.

Then there's the corner drug dealer/hit man. If you dare, catch up to him and interview him. He'll go to great lengths to show you he's just a guy trying to make a living, giving people a product they want very, very much. I wonder if Earl Bradley, the Delaware pediatrician who raped at least 100 2- and 3-year old girls, thinks of himself as fundamentally good? He even videotaped many of the rapes. What was he thinking?

Flitting thoughts along these lines went through my head when I saw the book I Wear the Black Hat: Grappling with Villains (Real and Imagined) by Chuck Klosterman. I've been hoping to find a book that delves into the possibility that some people actually choose to be evil. The jacket blurb raised my hopes, claiming the book is about people who wanted to be evil. That is as far as it went.

Starting with a discussion of rock bands he hated, the author primarily discusses people who are hated by others, whether or not they actually did anything evil. He derives a rule (we can call it Chuck's Rule of Evil): The villain is the one who knows the most and cares the least. The poster boy for this rule is supposedly Newt Gingrich. Howzatt? His "Contract for America" did more good for this country than any congressional action since. There is no mention in the book of something many folks consider evil, Newt's tendency to have affairs, but wait to file for divorce when the current wife is badly ill.

Klosterman goes on to various other public figures and groups, including a couple of really witless comedians and the rap group N.W.A. (who practically invented Gangsta Rap), and mid-book he discusses sports teams, dwelling on the Oakland Raiders. Now the Raiders' owner Al Davis seems to revel in a bad boy image, with his rule book centered on "Just Win, Baby!". But I suspect, inside, he thinks, "I am such a good coach" (Or thought, since he has now died).

The obligatory chapter on Adolph Hitler, which also mentions Stalin and Mao, really goes nowhere. Hitler is the exception that tests the Rule, because, whether he really knew the most or not, he certainly cared the most. But everything that can be known about Hitler has been written hundreds of times, so all that is left are speculations.

In the end, Klosterman admits that the adage, "he who writes of others writes of himself" is true. The book isn't about whether the hated people he writes about are/were really bad, but about the hatred (or not) he and others feel towards them. We are left with the question, who is worse, the hater or the hated one? In most cases, if there is someone or something you really hate, you'd do well to take a long, thoughtful look in the mirror.

Wednesday, August 11, 2010

As it is so it does

kw: book reviews, nonfiction, philosophy, evil

"Evil is as evil does." Isn't that the proverb? Not according to Terry Eagleton in On Evil. In this small, but wide-ranging book, he draws upon literature, theology, philosophy and contemporary history and culture to examine a phenomenon so many would think outmoded, even passé, and certainly not a fit subject for polite discourse.

Fully half the book draws upon fiction, for it is in fiction that our understanding as a human people is tested and either confirmed or found wanting. William Golding has examined evil in all its viciousness and banality over a long career, most notably with Lord of the Flies. The discussion begins with the anti-character Pincher Martin by Golding, and Milton's Mephistopheles in Paradise Lost is a necessary stop along the way, of course, but the author returns most often to the tragedies of William Shakespeare, particularly Macbeth and Othello.

Taking Iago of Othello as prototypical in the English oeuvre, Eagleton concludes that true evil is purposeless, destructive for the sake of destruction, and as causeless as God. This is ironic, as his own Marxism is the most atheistic of ideologies. But he's just getting warmed up. His second section examines philosophical and theological treatments, from theodicy to the nihilism of Schopenhauer.

Freud is brought in as having identified the evil in any of us with the death drive (most of us know it by the term death wish), that longing for nothingness, that existential angst that threatens to overcome us when we realize we can't have it all. Turned inward, it leads to suicide; turned outward, it leads to mass murder, or at least petty mayhem of all sorts. In most of us, subjugated and denied, it results in the dragging, enervating depression that dogs our days in "the rat race."

He starts to go seriously awry when he restricts his discussion of religious philosophy to two viewpoints: Roman Catholicism and "Moral Majority" puritanism. Both are rooted in asceticism, which is fundamentally not Biblical; Jesus said, "I came that they may have Life, and have it abundantly." But he cannot see beyond the crucifix, claiming that "Christian belief is that God achieves supreme self-expression in a tortured human body." (p 67) Now that is evil! Yet it is entirely expectable in a Marxist.

Strangely, he gets around to the "abundant life" statement, using it to support his contention of the purposelessness of evil, writing that the evil "are those who are deficient in the art of living." (p 128) Coming in a chapter titled "Obscene Enjoyment", that is so trite it beggars belief. The elephant strove and delivered a mouse. By the time the final chapter comes around, he has almost defined evil out of existence. When Jesus said, "Father forgive them, for they don't know what they are doing," it was not a general statement, but Eagleton takes it to be. Stephen echoed it while being stoned, "Let not this sin be held to their charge," accurately naming the sin while praying for its forgiveness. It was still a sin. What made these murders evil was that they were thought righteous by those doing them.

Here we come to the crux of the matter for me. The author uses Jesus' statement to say that, because the purpose was thought to be noble, the crucifiers of Jesus (and the stoners of Stephen by extension) "are perhaps not beyond the pale." But now he is painted into a corner, stating immediately afterward that "Stalin and Mao murdered for what they was as an honorable end, and if they are not beyond the moral pale then it is hard to know who is." (p 145) I agree with half of this statement; those two monsters are most certainly evil, even the epitome of it. But the first half? Ha! They claimed their purposes were noble, but clearly did not believe it, as even a cursory understanding of their more private utterances will attest. They did not care; good or evil were alike to them.

Thus, by the example of Mao and Stalin, and indeed Hitler, and in contradistinction to the author's thesis, we find that the evil are purposeful, often very purposeful. The banality of evil so often remarked upon is not in them, it is in the armies of lesser people "doing their job" at the behest of purposeful, powerful but uncaring leaders. It is in the clerks and laborers, the fillers of forms and diggers of mass graves, the makers of nerve gas or Uzis who go home to play with their children. But there is no banality about a Josef Stalin, none whatever. He knows what he is about, and it is all about him: his power, his image, his comfort, his country, his political system.

That archetypical Evil One, Lucifer, with his seven "I will" statements in Isaiah 14, says to God in effect, "I don't like the way you are running the Universe, so I will take over." This, the basis of Nietzsche's will to power, is the root of evil (and to calm a quibble, the "love of money" is "a root of all kinds of evils", not as the KJV translates it "the root of all evil"). To take over God's work is evil; to cooperate with God in His work is good. The rest doesn't matter.